Foot ulceration is a serious complication of diabetes and associated with elevated plantar pressures during walking. Custom accommodative insoles are most effective when informed by dynamic pressure data; however, static pressure collection offers a faster and more clinically feasible alternative. The ability of static pressure measurements to predict dynamic high-pressure regions remains unclear and needs investigation.This study compared peak plantar pressure, sensor-level correlations, and predictive performance of static pressure thresholds from static in-shoe and static barefoot data relative to dynamic in-shoe data. Plantar pressures were collected from 31 feet in 18 participants with elevated dynamic in-shoe forefoot pressures. Dynamic high-pressure regions were defined as regions exceeding 200 kPa. Sensor-level correlations were calculated, and receiver operating characteristic curves were used to determine static thresholds. Agreement metrics, including Dice coefficient, sensitivity, and positive predictive value, were evaluated.Sensor-level Pearson and Spearman correlations were higher for static versus dynamic in-shoe data than for static barefoot comparisons (p<0.001). Static thresholds were 40.4 and 55.8 kPa for in-shoe and barefoot data respectively. Despite moderate to strong correlations, Dice coefficients were low, indicating minimal spatial overlap between static and dynamic high-pressure regions. High sensitivity with low positive predictive value demonstrated that static thresholds overestimated the location and extent of dynamic high-pressure regions.These findings indicate that static pressure measurements, despite improved clinical feasibility, cannot reliably identify dynamic in-shoe high-pressure regions. Insole design based on static pressures may lead to overly conservative offloading and reduced specificity, reinforcing the need for dynamic pressure data in clinical practice.