Comparison of Monte Carlo and analytical dose computations for intensity modulated proton therapy
Authors:
- 1 February 2018
- journal article
- research article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 63 (4) , 045003
Abstract
To evaluate the effect of approximations in clinical analytical calculations performed by a treatment planning system (TPS) on dosimetric indices in intensity modulated proton therapy. TPS calculated dose distributions were compared with dose distributions as estimated by Monte Carlo (MC) simulations, calculated with the fast dose calculator (FDC) a system previously benchmarked to full MC. This study analyzed a total of 525 patients for four treatment sites (brain, head-and-neck, thorax and prostate). Dosimetric indices (D02, D05, D20, D50, D95, D98, EUD and Mean Dose) and a gamma-index analysis were utilized to evaluate the differences. The gamma-index passing rates for a 3%/3 mm criterion for voxels with a dose larger than 10% of the maximum dose had a median larger than 98% for all sites. The median difference for all dosimetric indices for target volumes was less than 2% for all cases. However, differences for target volumes as large as 10% were found for 2% of the thoracic patients. For organs at risk (OARs), the median absolute dose difference was smaller than 2 Gy for all indices and cohorts. However, absolute dose differences as large as 10 Gy were found for some small volume organs in brain and head-and-neck patients. This analysis concludes that for a fraction of the patients studied, TPS may overestimate the dose in the target by as much as 10%, while for some OARs the dose could be underestimated by as much as 10 Gy. Monte Carlo dose calculations may be needed to ensure more accurate dose computations to improve target coverage and sparing of OARs in proton therapy.Keywords
Funding Information
- Cancer Prevention and Research Institute of Texas (RP160232)
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Intensity modulated proton therapy treatment planning using single‐field optimization: The impact of monitor unit constraints on plan qualityMedical Physics, 2010
- Clinical implementation of full Monte Carlo dose calculation in proton beam therapyPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2008
- Assessment of the accuracy of an MCNPX-based Monte Carlo simulation model for predicting three-dimensional absorbed dose distributionsPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2008
- Monte Carlo calculations and measurements of absorbed dose per monitor unit for the treatment of uveal melanoma with proton therapyPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2008
- Geometric interpretation of the dose distribution comparison technique: Interpolation‐free calculationMedical Physics, 2008
- A pencil beam algorithm for intensity modulated proton therapy derived from Monte Carlo simulationsPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 2005
- A proton dose calculation algorithm for conformal therapy simulations based on Molière's theory of lateral deflectionsMedical Physics, 1998
- A technique for calculating range spectra of charged particle beams distal to thick inhomogeneitiesMedical Physics, 1998
- A pencil beam algorithm for proton dose calculationsPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 1996
- The calibration of CT Hounsfield units for radiotherapy treatment planningPhysics in Medicine & Biology, 1996