Towards methodologically more rigorous corpus-based translation studies
- 1 December 2012
- journal article
- Published by Akademiai Kiado Zrt. in Across Languages and Cultures
- Vol. 13 (2) , 137-143
Abstract
This paper argues in favour of a more rigorous methodology for corpusbased translation studies. According to our proposal, research papers in the field should be minimally required to (i) provide a meticulous overview of the corpus materials used and of the exact procedures for selecting, annotating and sifting the data; (ii) comment on any specific problems encountered during data selection and annotation, including explicit and motivated statements as to the solutions being adopted; (iii) include elaborate testing for statistical significance as a complement of, not in opposition to, thorough qualitative analysis. This approach, we suggest, not only offers a way around many theoretical and methodological problems that have been noted in the recent literature (e.g., House 2008; Becher 2010; Bernardini and Ferraresi 2011), it also facilitates more rigorous replication and reinterpretation of previous work, potentially leading to a re-assessment of some popular but unproven assumptions such as the notion that linguistic features in translations are independent of source language or genre. By thus moving forward the empirical cycle of testing and re-testing of hypotheses, the methodology advocated here encourages collaborative research, and leads ultimately to more scientific progress.Keywords
This publication has 9 references indexed in Scilit:
- Is translated language more standardized than non-translated language?2012
- Quantitative Methods in Corpus-Based Translation Studies2012
- Practice, Description and Theory Come Together – Normalization or Interference in Italian Technical Translation?Meta : Journal Des Traducteursmeta : / Translators’ Journal, 2011
- Abandoning the notion of “translation-inherent” explicitation: Against a dogma of translation studiesAcross Languages and Cultures, 2010
- A corpus-based view of similarity and difference in translationCorpus Studies of Language Through Time, 2004
- Introducing Corpora in Translation Studies2004
- Corpus-based Translation Studies2002
- Corpora in Translation Studies1995
- Text and Technology1993