The epistemic status of derivational robustness
Open Access
- 31 July 2025
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Journal for Philosophy of Science
- Vol. 15 (3) , 1-18
Abstract
A proposition is derivationally robust precisely when it is a prediction of each model in an ensemble of models. We show that a recent and influential Bayesian defense of the epistemic merits of derivational robustness analysis faces substantial obstacles. The main reason for this is that a Bayesian characterization of derivational robustness requires one to condition on a logical or mathematical truth. Standardly, however, conditioning on a logical or mathematical truth cannot raise or lower the probability of any proposition, which means confirmation in such cases is impossible. What is required for a Bayesian defense of derivational robustness to be plausible is the adoption of a non-standard probability calculus, but the details of such an account have yet to be worked out in sufficient detail. We close by arguing against the view that agreement among multiple models has a confirmatory status that is the same or similar to agreement among multiple measurements of some quantity. It is straightforward to show that agreement among measurements has epistemic significance. This is not true for derivational robustness.Keywords
This publication has 40 references indexed in Scilit:
- The Unity of Robustness: Why Agreement Across Model Reports is Just as Valuable as Agreement Among ExperimentsErkenntnis, 2022
- Philosophy and Climate Science2018
- The Significance of Robust Climate Projections2018
- Derivational Robustness and Indirect ConfirmationErkenntnis, 2017
- Allocating confirmation with derivational robustnessPhilosophical Studies, 2016
- Robustness, Reliability, and Overdetermination (1981)2012
- Evidence and Evolution2008
- Common fate, similarity, and other indices of the status of aggregates of persons as social entitiesSystems Research and Behavioral Science, 2007
- The Neutral Theory of Molecular Evolution1983
- Construct validity in psychological tests.Psychological Bulletin, 1955