No appeal to moral status required: rethinking the argument for the moral advantage of stem cell-based embryo models in research
Open Access
- 1 October 2026
- journal article
- scientific contribution
- Published by Springer Nature in Medicine, Health Care and Philosophy
- p. 1-13
Abstract
Stem Cell-Based Embryo Models (SCBEMs) have been welcomed enthusiastically because they would allow the study of specific phases of human embryonic development without resorting to embryos produced in vitro. This enthusiasm is based on the idea that research on such models is morally less problematic than research on human embryos. However, this position has recently been challenged, as some authors argue that there are no good reasons to attribute a different moral status to SCBEMs compared to embryos, and the focus on such models risks obscuring an appropriate evaluation of embryonic experimentation rather than representing a genuine moral advancement. In light of this disagreement, I discuss what I call the Argument for the Moral Advantage of SCBEMs and aim to defend it against recent criticisms. I first present the standard version of the argument and argue that it assumes embryos possess direct moral status based on their potential to become persons. Then, after discussing criticisms of the standard version, I explore revising the argument. I first consider relying on the embryos’ symbolic moral value; after dismissing this move, I introduce a revised version of the argument based on the pro tanto minimization of moral conflicts, rather than on embryos’ moral status or value. After defending the revised argument against several objections, I finally discuss regulatory issues concerning SCBEMs research.Keywords
Funding Information
- University of Zurich
This publication has 38 references indexed in Scilit:
- A 3D in vitro model for studying human implantation and implantation failureCell, 2025
- Stem cell-based embryo models: The 2021 ISSCR stem cell guidelines revisitedStem Cell Reports, 2025
- Stem Cell and Synthetic Embryo Models: Advances, Applications, and Ethical ConsiderationsStem Cell Reviews and Reports, 2025
- The Ethics of Stem Cell-Based Embryo-Like StructuresJournal of Bioethical Inquiry, 2024
- Potentiality switches and epistemic uncertainty: the Argument from Potential in times of human embryo-like structuresMedicine, Health Care and Philosophy, 2023
- An ethical framework for human embryology with embryo modelsCell, 2023
- Modeling post-implantation stages of human development into early organogenesis with stem-cell-derived peri-gastruloidsCell, 2023
- Human stem cell-derived embryo models: Toward ethically appropriate regulations and policiesCell Stem Cell, 2023
- The Reasonableness Standard for Conscientious Objection in HealthcareJournal of Bioethical Inquiry, 2022
- Avoiding the potentiality trap: thinking about the moral status of synthetic embryosMonash Bioethics Review, 2019