Abstract
I should begin by thanking Brian Berkey for his thoughtful discussion of my paper. As will be clear from what follows, I think that, in several instances, Berkey’s discussion goes beyond a consideration of anything I proposed. That is all to the good, however, as it prompts his searching claims about some fundamental issues concerning agent-centred prerogatives and egalitarianism. It seems to me, as I will explain further below, that what emerges from his discussion is not a ‘defence’ of Cohen, but rather a novel view that differs from both Cohen’s view and my own.

This publication has 17 references indexed in Scilit: