Optimization of Time Windowing Technique for Closed-Loop Circuit Cosimulation Using WR Method
Open Access
- 24 November 2025
- journal article
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Open Journal of Industry Applications
- Vol. 6, 852-866
Abstract
Power electronic systems are widely used for efficient power processing across various applications. However, due to their nonlinear behavior and susceptibility to disturbances, modeling and simulation are essential for fully understanding their complex interactions. The waveform relaxation (WR) method is employed to solve subsystems independently, with data exchanged until convergence is reached, offering flexibility in selecting solvers and integration techniques. In power electronics, applying the WR method with time windowing improves simulation stability and accuracy by introducing an equation to determine the optimal number of time windows. A time windowing technique is proposed, for the first time, for the co-simulation of a closed-loop power circuit divided into a first subsystem (converter) and a second subsystem (Proportional-Integral controller). These two subsystems are supposed to be designed by two different entities, which are not allowed to exchange their respective models for intellectual property reasons. The time windowing WR method is applied to transfer the data from subsystem 1 to 2. More importantly, an analytical model for the implementation of a time windowing WR technique is developed. This equation allows a deterministic choice of the number of time windows at each iteration, for convergence, based on windowing size and simulation parameters. Results show consistent output within a specified voltage range, with reduced CPU simulation time compared to co-simulation with an arbitrary selection of numbers of time windows, while being comparable to the full system simulation. The proposed technique is implemented with an input voltage range of 1.8-3 $V$, resulting in consistent outputs of 3.3 $V$ in both continuous- and discrete-time simulation modes. The comparative analysis demonstrates that with an increased number of iterations, the elapsed time is 11.1% and 5.6% faster for continuous- and discrete-time simulation modes, respectively, compared to a co-simulation with time windows. Furthermore, the time windowing WR method closely aligns with the full system result, with only a slight difference in elapsed time. Additionally, to validate the proposed analytical model using the time windowing WR technique in a closed-loop circuit, the buck converter is evaluated and compared without the full system. These results highlight the accuracy of WR with time windowing method and illustrate the quicker convergence achieved when used in circuit co-simulation.Keywords
Funding Information
- Agence Nationale de la Recherche (ANR-19-CE05-0016-05)
This publication has 28 references indexed in Scilit:
- Principles of Power Electronics2023
- Numerical investigation on model predictive control of portable electronic devices based on MATLAB/FLUENT co-simulation frameworkApplied Thermal Engineering, 2023
- The state-of-the-art of power electronics converters configurations in electric vehicle technologiesPower Electronic Devices and Components, 2022
- Design and analysis of genetic algorithm and BP neural network based PID control for boost converter applied in renewable power generationsIET Renewable Power Generation, 2021
- Branch-and-price-and-cut methods for the electric vehicle routing problem with time windowsInternational Journal of Production Research, 2021
- A transformerless high gain dc–dc boost converter with reduced voltage stressInternational Transactions on Electrical Energy Systems, 2021
- Modelling and Co-simulation of hybrid vehicles: A thermal management perspectiveApplied Thermal Engineering, 2020
- Co-simulation of Fuzzy Logic Control for a DC–DC Buck Converter in Cascade SystemAdvances in Intelligent Systems and Computing, 2020
- Power Electronic Converters Modeling and Control2014
- Waveform Relaxation1987