A systematic characterization of plastic scintillation dosimeters response in magnetic fields: II. Monte Carlo simulations
Open Access
- 7 May 2025
- journal article
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 70 (10) , 105004
Abstract
Purpose. This study aims to investigate and validate the response of plastic scintillation dosimeters (PSDs) in the presence of magnetic fields using Monte Carlo simulations, focusing on the accuracy of electron fluence, dose calculations, and the optical processes of scintillation and Cherenkov radiation. Methods. Monte Carlo simulations, using EGSnrc and TOPAS, of the PSD response under magnetic fields were performed. First, electron fluence simulations were conducted with three different physics lists g4em-penelope, g4em-standard_opt3 and g4em-standard_opt4, with the goal of benchmarking their performance in magnetic fields. Secondly, a Fano test for dose calculations was performed using only the g4em-penelope physics list. Thirdly, the Cherenkov process under magnetic fields was validated against theoretical predictions. Finally, a PSD probe was modeled and simulated, with results compared against measurements. Results. The g4em-penelope physics list demonstrated a most balanced performance, showing the closest agreement with EGSnrc simulations and lower variability in magnetic fields than g4em-standard_opt4. Fano test results showed an accuracy of at least 0.36% for dose calculations. Simulations of Cherenkov radiation in ideal conditions were in agreement with theoretical predictions at both 0 T and 1.5 T. Monte Carlo simulations successfully reproduced experimental trends for Cherenkov radiation under magnetic fields. However, discrepancies were found, with deviations of up to 7.7% when electrons were deflected towards the tip and up to 21.0% in the opposite direction, likely due to modeling limitations. A key result is that Monte Carlo simulations of the scintillation process in magnetic fields failed to reproduce experimental observations. While experimental results showed a significant effect of magnetic fields on scintillation yield, the simulations did not reflect this behavior. Conclusion. This study establishes that TOPAS, specifically using the g4em-penelope physics list, is a reliable tool for simulating dose, electron fluence, and Cherenkov radiation in the presence of magnetic fields. However, significant discrepancies were observed in the scintillation processes, where Monte Carlo simulations failed to reproduce the effect of magnetic fields seen in experimental measurements. These findings point out the need for further refinement of simulation models, particularly in accurately representing scintillation under magnetic fields.Keywords
Funding Information
- Natural Sciences and Engineering Research Council of Canada (Discovery grants RGPIN 2019-05038)
- Mitacs (IT30116)
This publication has 46 references indexed in Scilit:
- Field output correction factors using a scintillation detectorMedical Physics, 2025
- Characteristics of a plastic scintillation detector in photon beam dosimetryJournal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics, 2023
- Proton dosimetry in a magnetic field: Measurement and calculation of magnetic field correction factors for a plane‐parallel ionization chamberMedical Physics, 2023
- Dosimetric characterization of a novel commercial plastic scintillation detector with an MR‐LinacMedical Physics, 2023
- Energy calibration of EJ-301 scintillation detector using unfolding methods for fast neutron measurementNuclear Instruments and Methods in Physics Research Section A: Accelerators, Spectrometers, Detectors and Associated Equipment, 2022
- Report on G4‐Med, a Geant4 benchmarking system for medical physics applications developed by the Geant4 Medical Simulation Benchmarking GroupMedical Physics, 2020
- Monte Carlo modeling of the influence of strong magnetic fields on the stem‐effect in plastic scintillation detectors used in radiotherapy dosimetryMedical Physics, 2020
- The TOPAS tool for particle simulation, a Monte Carlo simulation tool for physics, biology and clinical researchPhysica Medica, 2020
- Quantifying the impact of lead doping on plastic scintillator response to radiationMedical Physics, 2019
- Dosimetry in clinical static magnetic fields using plastic scintillation detectorsRadiation Measurements, 2013