Comparison of Wavefront-Guided Femtosecond LASIK and Optimized SMILE for Correction of Moderate-to-High Astigmatism
Authors:
- Xinheng ZhaoXZXinheng Zhao
- Lin ZhangLZLin Zhang
- Jiaonan MaJMJiaonan Ma
- Mengdi LiMLMengdi Li
- Jiamei ZhangJZJiamei Zhang
- Xing ZhaoXZXing Zhao
- Yan WangYWYan Wang
- 1 March 2021
- journal article
- research article
- Published by SLACK, Inc. in Journal of Refractive Surgery
- Vol. 37 (3) , 166-173
Abstract
PURPOSE: To compare refractive outcomes, higher order aberrations (HOAs), and the changes in contrast sensitivity after wavefront-guided femtosecond laser–assisted in situ keratomileusis (WFG LASIK) and optimized small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE) for moderate-to-high astigmatism correction. METHODS: This prospective, randomized study included 87 eyes: 40 eyes in the WFG LASIK group and 47 eyes in the SMILE group. Manual cyclotorsion compensation by marking the horizontal axis before SMILE surgery was used for optimized SMILE. Refractive diopter, aberrations, and contrast sensitivity were assessed 3 months postoperatively. The Alpins vector analysis method was used to analyze the astigmatic changes after surgery. RESULTS: There were no significant differences in the corrected distance visual acuity and refraction between the two groups after surgery. The fitted curve of surgically induced astigmatism versus target induced astigmatism was described as y = 0.9905 x + 0.0009 in the WFG LASIK group and y = 0.9672 x + 0.0026 in the SMILE group. The percentage of corneal astigmatism axis change within 5 degrees was statistically significant (chi-square test: 10.632, P = .001). HOAs increased in both the WFG LASIK and SMILE groups after surgery ( t = −3.655, P = .001, t = −3.784, P = .001, respectively). However, comparison of the changes of HOAs between both groups was not significant ( t = −0.565, P = .575). The improvement in contrast sensitivity in the WFG LASIK group was significantly higher than that in the SMILE group. CONCLUSIONS: WFG LASIK and optimized SMILE can achieve similar outcomes for astigmatism correction. Optimized SMILE with marking could achieve good astigmatism correction, even without an eye tracking system. [ J Refract Surg . 2021;37(3):166–173.]Keywords
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- Comparison of Corneal Shape Changes and Aberrations Induced By FS-LASIK and SMILE for MyopiaJournal of Refractive Surgery, 2015
- Vector analysis of low to moderate astigmatism with small incision lenticule extraction (SMILE): results of a 1-year follow-upBMC Ophthalmology, 2015
- Topographic Analysis of the Centration of the Treatment Zone After SMILE for Myopia and Comparison to FS-LASIK: Subjective Versus Objective AlignmentJournal of Refractive Surgery, 2014
- Corneal biomechanical effects: Small-incision lenticule extraction versus femtosecond laser–assisted laser in situ keratomileusisJournal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery, 2014
- Correction of Myopic Astigmatism With Small Incision Lenticule ExtractionJournal of Refractive Surgery, 2014
- Comparison of methods to measure corneal power for intraocular lens power calculation using a rotating Scheimpflug cameraJournal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery, 2013
- Small-incision lenticule extraction for moderate to high myopia: Predictability, safety, and patient satisfactionJournal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery, 2012
- Novel Objective Method for Comparing Ablation Centration With and Without Pupil Tracking Following Myopic Laser In Situ Keratomileusis Using the Bausch & Lomb Technolas 217ACornea, 2009
- Evaluation of iris recognition system for wavefront-guided laser in situ keratomileusis for myopic astigmatismJournal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery, 2008
- Photorefractive keratectomy with aspheric profile of ablation versus conventional photorefractive keratectomy for myopia correctionJournal of Cataract & Refractive Surgery, 2006