Perceptual attention and indeterminacy: Merleau-Pontyian challenges to naïve realism and representationalism
Open Access
- 5 May 2026
- journal article
- Published by Springer Nature in Phenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences
Abstract
In Phenomenology of Perception , Merleau-Ponty criticizes what he calls “Empiricist” and “Intellectualist” accounts of perception. One of his central criticisms is that both misconstrue the relationship between perception and attention. As a result, neither can tell a coherent story about the role of attention in perceptual knowledge. In this paper, we extract the core lessons of Merleau-Ponty’s discussion and apply them to some prominent contemporary accounts of the relation between attention and perception, namely Sebastian Watzl’s (2017) and Bill Brewer’s (2013). Although operating within very different frameworks—Watzl is a representationalist, whereas Brewer is a naïve realist—we show that they encounter a similar set of problems, which are highlighted in Merleau-Ponty’s discussion. We end by providing a set of constraints that any adequate account of the relation between attention and perception must meet, and sketch how the naïve realist and representationalist, each in their own way, might satisfy these constraints.Keywords
Funding Information
- Københavns Universitet
This publication has 58 references indexed in Scilit:
- Attention, as a Concept in Phenomenology2024
- Naïve realism and sensorimotor theorySynthese, 2024
- Structuring embodied minds: attention and perceptual agencyPhilosophical Studies, 2024
- What attention is. The priority structure accountWIREs Cognitive Science, 2022
- Rethinking naive realismPhilosophical Studies, 2018
- Habit and Attention2013
- Phenomenology of Thematics and of the Pure Ego: Studies of the Relation Between Gestalt Theory and Phenomenology2010
- The Collected Works of Aron Gurwitsch (1901-1973)2010
- Motor intentionality and the case of SchneiderPhenomenology and the Cognitive Sciences, 2009
- Analyses Concerning Passive and Active Synthesis2001