Large-scale deployment of proton exchange membrane water electrolyzers (PEMWEs) is crucial for producing clean and economically viable hydrogen to create hydrogen-based energy ecosystems that can replace existing carbon-intensive processes. Efficient operation of PEMWEs requires the use of thinner membranes to reduce ohmic losses as well as the differential pressure operation to increase the overall system efficiency. The high differential pressure operation of PEMWEs with thin membranes results in significant hydrogen crossover from cathode to anode. This crossover-H2 has considerable implications on PEMWE performance, durability, as well as operational safety. In this work, we develop a method to accurately quantify hydrogen crossover rates in PEMWEs operating at high differential pressure. Our analysis shows that crossover-H2 is oxidized at the anode catalyst layer resulting in measurable hydrogen oxidation reaction (HOR) currents. We combine this HOR current measurement with online gas chromatography with thermal conductivity detector to determine H2 concentration in the anode outlet and also calculate H2 crossover rates at various operating current and differential pressures (up to 30 bar). Further, we use this methodology to evaluate the effect of porous transport layer (PTL) coatings (Pt, Ir, and Au) on the HOR current as well as the hydrogen crossover rate in PEMWEs. Acknowledgment: This research is supported by the U.S. Department of Energy (DOE) Hydrogen and Fuel Cell Technologies Office (HFTO) through the Hydrogen from Next-generation Electrolyzers of Water (H2NEW) consortium.