GSGeorg Schiemer

Georg Schiemer

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Georg Schiemer has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Two Ways to Think About (Implicit) Structure

    by Georg Schiemer

    The article compares two ways to think about the implicit structure of systems studied in pure mathematics. The first approach specifies implicit structure in terms of formal languages, relying on a model-theoretic notion of definability. The second approach defines the notion in terms of invariance criteria. The structural features of a given system are often considered to be properties which are invariant under specific transformations of the system. In the paper, I analyze these two approaches to implicit structure in terms of invariance and definability conditions by drawing to the field of finite geometry. I then explore their formal relationship in the framework of relational algebra, based on the concepts of Galois closures and Krasner algebras. Finally, I examine the equivalence of mathematical systems with respect to their implicit structure in terms of the model-theoretic notion of bi-interpretability.

  • Open Access

    Hilberts Einfluss auf Carnap

    by Georg Schiemer

    Zusammenfassung: David Hilbert (1862–1943) gilt mit seinen Beiträgen zur algebraischen Invariantentheorie, zur mathematischen Physik, sowie zu den Grundlagen der Mathematik als führender Mathematiker des späten 19. und frühen 20. Jahrhunderts (Gray 2000).

  • Open Access

    Carnap über Strukturen

    by Christoph Limbeck-Lilienau, Georg Schiemer

    Zusammenfassung: Strukturalismus bildet ein zentrales Thema in Carnaps philosophischem Werk. Der Fokus auf Strukturen und strukturelle oder formale Eigenschaften von Relationen verbindet dessen frühe Arbeiten zur Philosophie der Mathematik und zur Konstitutionstheorie im Logischen Aufbau mit späteren Beiträgen zur Wissenschaftstheorie (Friedman 1999; Schiemer 2000). Doch wie wird der Begriff der Struktur bei Carnap genau verstanden? Die Ursprünge seiner Auffassung liegen in Carnaps Arbeiten zur Logik und den Grundlagen der Mathematik aus den 1920ern, in denen erstmals eine relationslogische Bestimmung des Begriffs vorgeschlagen wird.

  • Open Access

    Hilbert on categoricity and completeness

    by Eduardo N. Giovannini, Georg Schiemer

    The article analyzes Hilbert’s early contributions to the metatheoretic concept of categoricity and its relation to other completeness properties of axiomatic theories. For this purpose, we present a categoricity proof of the axiom system for real analysis first sketched in his lecture course Logische Prinzipien des mathematischen Denkens from 1905. This result will be compared with Dedekind’s well-known categoricity theorem for arithmetic from 1888 as well as with Hilbert’s informal remarks on the completeness of his axiom system for Euclidean geometry presented in Grundlagen der Geometrie (1899). Given these early metatheoretical results, we will address Hilbert’s motivations for the use of categoricity arguments in the foundations of mathematics.


  • Open Access

    Hilbert’s Early Metatheory Revisited

    by Eduardo N. Giovannini, Georg Schiemer

    The article offers a novel reconstruction of Hilbert’s early metatheory of formal axiomatics. His foundational work from the turn of the last century is often regarded as a central contribution to a “model-theoretic” viewpoint in modern logic and mathematics. The article will re-assess Hilbert’s role in the development of model theory by focusing on two aspects of his contributions to the axiomatic foundations of geometry and analysis. First, we examine Hilbert’s conception of mathematical theories and their interpretations; in particular, we argue that his early semantic views can be understood in terms of a notion of translational isomorphism between models of an axiomatic theory. Second, we offer a logical reconstruction of his consistency and independence results in geometry in terms of the notion of interpretability between theories.


  • Open Access

    Structuralism and informal provability

    by Georg Schiemer, John Wigglesworth

    Mathematical structuralism can be understood as a theory of mathematical ontology, of the objects that mathematics is about. It can also be understood as a theory of the semantics for mathematical discourse, of how and to what mathematical terms refer. In this paper we propose an epistemological interpretation of mathematical structuralism. According to this interpretation, the main epistemological claim is that mathematical knowledge is purely structural in character; mathematical statements contain purely structural information. To make this more precise, we invoke a notion that is central to mathematical epistemology, the notion of (informal) proof. Appealing to the notion of proof, an epistemological version of the structuralist thesis can be formulated as: Every mathematical statement that is provable expresses purely structural information. We introduce a bi-modal framework that formalizes the notions of structural information and informal provability in order to draw connections between them and confirm that the epistemological structuralist thesis holds.

  • Open Access

    Modal Structuralism with Theoretical Terms

    by Holger Andreas, Georg Schiemer

    In this paper, we aim to explore connections between a Carnapian semantics of theoretical terms and an eliminative structuralist approach in the philosophy of mathematics. Specifically, we will interpret the language of Peano arithmetic by applying the modal semantics of theoretical terms introduced in Andreas (Synthese 174(3):367–383, 2010). We will thereby show that the application to Peano arithmetic yields a formal semantics of universal structuralism, i.e., the view that ordinary mathematical statements in arithmetic express general claims about all admissible interpretations of the Peano axioms. Moreover, we compare this application with the modal structuralism by Hellman (Mathematics without numbers: towards a modal-structural interpretation. Oxford University Press: Oxford, 1989), arguing that it provides us with an easier epistemology of statements in arithmetic.


  • Introduction to Special Issue: Foundations of Mathematical Structuralism

    by Georg Schiemer, John Wigglesworth

    Structuralism, the view that mathematics is the science of structures, can be characterized as a philosophical response to a general structural turn in modern mathematics. Structuralists aim to understand the ontological, epistemological, and semantical implications of this structural approach in mathematics. Theories of structuralism began to develop following the publication of Paul Benacerraf’s paper ‘What numbers could not be’ in 1965. These theories include non-eliminative approaches, formulated in a background ontology of sui generis structures, such as Stewart Shapiro’s ante rem structuralism and Michael Resnik’s pattern structuralism. In contrast, there are also eliminativist accounts of structuralism, such as Geoffrey Hellman’s modal structuralism, which avoids sui generis structures. These research projects have guided...