TEThórhallur Eythórsson

Thórhallur Eythórsson

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Thórhallur Eythórsson has a total of 16 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • The emergence of oblique subjects

    by Sigríður Sæunn Sigurðardóttir, Thórhallur Eythórsson

    Predicate-specific oblique subjects have emerged throughout the history of Icelandic. The novel contribution of this paper is spelling out the precise mechanisms of the changes. We focus on three general processes: Oblique-Case Substitution (OCS), Case-Preserving Anticausativization (CPA) and Argument Swapping (ARS). OCS involves morphosyntactic leveling targeting experiencer predicates, causing nominative experiencer subjects to be replaced by oblique ones. CPA is a special kind of anticausativization, where the oblique case of the object of a transitive verb matches the case of the subject of the corresponding anticausative, resulting in an oblique-subject construction. Finally, ARS involves a reanalysis of an object as a subject. The oblique subject in dative-nominative structures, in particular with st -predicates (‘middles’), arose through ARS from earlier nominative-dative structures, motivated by the animacy of the dative.

  • Open Access

    „Að slepptu tjillinu": Sjálfstæður forsetningarliður með lýsingarhætti

    by Ingunn Hreinberg Indriðadóttir, Þórhallur Eyþórsson

    Sjálfstæður forsetningarliður með lýsingarhætti (SFL) er íslensk setningagerð sem hefur hingað til lítið verið fjallað um, hvað þá að hún hafi verið greind málfræðilega á fullnægjandi hátt. Unnt er að skilgreina SFL sem smásetningu sem inniheldur frumlagsnafnlið og lýsingarhátt í nútíð eða þátíð þar sem fallinu er stjórnað af forsetningunni að. Í forníslensku koma bæði þágufalls- og þolfallsnafnliðir fyrir í setningagerðinni en í nútímaíslensku virðist aðeins vera dæmi um þágufallsliði. Enn fremur er dreifing lýsingarháttar nútíðar og þátíðar ólík í forn- og nútímaíslensku. Auk þess eru hliðstæðar setningagerðir til í skyldum málum, bæði innan og utan germönsku (t.d. í latínu og grísku). Lýsing okkar á SFL í nútímaíslensku byggir á ítarlegri vefrannsókn á setningagerðinni. Þessi aðferð var notuð til að sýna fram á að SFL er tiltölulega algengur í nútímaíslensku, bæði í formlegum og óformlegum málaðstæðum. Flest dæmin sem eru sýnd hér eru úr vefrannsókninni en önnur voru metin af fámennum hópi málnotenda í óformlegri matskönnun. Meðal þeirra atriða sem eru tekin til skoðunar eru setningafræðilegt hlutverk smásetningarinnar, málfræðihlutverk nafnliðarins og sagnanna, tíða- og horfasamband í SFL og orðaraðarmynstur innan setningagerðarinnar.

  • The alternating predicate puzzle

    by Jóhanna Barðdal, Thórhallur Eythórsson, Tonya Kim Dewey

    A long-standing divide between Icelandic and German in the literature takes for granted that there are non-nominative subjects in Icelandic, while corresponding arguments in German have been analyzed as objects (Zaenen et al. 1985;Sigurðsson 1989). This is based on two differences between these languages: (a) differences with regard to control and conjunction reduction and (b) apparent subject behavior of the nominative indat-nomconstructions in German. This article focuses on the latter, introducing into the discussion the concept of alternating predicates, that is,dat-nompredicates that systematically alternate between two diametrically-opposed argument structure constructions,dat-nomandnom-dat. A comparison between Icelandic and German shows that Icelandicdat-nompredicates are of two types, a non-alternatinglíkatype and an alternatingfalla í geðtype, whereas German seems to exhibit only the alternating type. On this assumption, the apparent subject behavior of the nominative in German is easily explained, since such occurrences in fact involve thenom-datconstruction and not thedat-nomconstruction. Therefore, the subject behavior of the nominative innom-datconstructions does not invalidate a subject analysis of the dative indat-nomconstructions in German. The analysis is couched in the framework of construction grammar.


  • Stability and change in Icelandic weather verbs

    by Sigríður Sæunn Sigurðardóttir, Thórhallur Eythórsson

    Contrary to previous claims, weather verbs in Icelandic are not “no-argument” predicates. Both in Old and Modern Icelandic they can appear with an NP either in nominative, accusative or dative case. It can be shown that in Modern Icelandic the NPs are subjects, and this is likely to have been the case in Old Icelandic. Diachronically, in addition to some changes in subject case marking (Nominative Substitution and Impersonalization), the main innovations in weather verbs involve the introduction of the “expletive” elements það and hann. On the whole, however, there is considerable stability in the use of weather verbs in the history of Icelandic. Not only are the lexical items nearly all the same, but a clear continuity in the syntax of weather expressions can be documented.


  • What is a subject

    by Jóhanna Barðdal, Thórhallur Eythórsson


  • The prepositional absolute construction in Icelandic

    by Thórhallur Eythórsson, Ingunn Hreinberg Indriðadóttir


  • Variation in oblique subject constructions in Insular Scandinavian

    by Thórhallur Eythórsson, Höskuldur Thráinsson

    This chapter reviews the division of morphological case into structural case and lexical case and the latter in turn into regular (thematic) and idiosyncratic case (Yip, Maling and Jackendoff 1987). The Case Directionality Hypothesis (Eythórsson 2002, 2015b) states that historical development of case is predictable if one assumes this division: structural case replaces lexical case and idiosyncratic lexical case will yield to regular (thematic) lexical case. This hypothesis is tested on data which were collected in projects on variation in subject case in Icelandic and Faroese. It is concluded that the development of subject case in Icelandic and Faroese is to a significant degree in accordance with the predictions of the CDH, but interesting exceptions are also described and discussed.


  • Dative subjects in Germanic

    by Jóhanna Barðdal, Carlee Arnett, Stephen Mark Carey, Thórhallur Eythórsson, Gard B. Jenset, Guus Kroonen, Adam Oberlin

    One of the functions of the dative is to mark non-prototypical subjects, i. e. subjects that somehow deviate from the agentive prototype. The Germanic languages, as all subbranches of Indo-European (cf. Barðdal et al. 2012. Reconstructing constructional semantics: The dative subject construction in Old Norse‐Icelandic, Latin, Ancient Greek, Old Russian and Old Lithuanian. Studies in Language 36(3). 511–547), exhibit structures where the subject or the subject-like argument is not in the nominative case, but in the accusative, dative or genitive, for instance. The focus of this article is on the dative, leaving accusative and genitive subjects aside, in particular homing in on lexical semantic similarities and differences between the individual Germanic languages. We compare Modern Icelandic, Modern Faroese, and Modern German, on the one hand, and the historical Germanic languages, i. e. Gothic, Old English, Old Saxon, Old High German, Middle English, Middle Dutch, Middle German, Old Norse-Icelandic and Old Swedish, on the other. The goal is to document the semantic development of the construction across time. This, in turn, is a part of a more general research program aiming at reconstructing the origin and the development of the Dative Subject Construction in Germanic and Indo-European. As the Germanic languages are both genealogically and areally related, we suggest a computational model aiming at disentangling genealogical and geographical factors, in order to estimate to which degree the two interact with each other across languages and across historical eras.


  • Dative case in Norwegian, Icelandic and Faroese: Preservation and non-preservation

    by Þórhallur Eyþórsson, Janne Bondi Johannessen, Signe Laake, Tor A. Åfarli

    This article investigates the morphosyntactic status of dative case in Norwegian, Icelandic, and Faroese. We hypothesize that these three languages represent three diachronic stages signalled synchronically by the degree of preservation or non-preservation of dative under movement. Thus, we explore the synchronic status of dative under passive movement and topicalization in the three languages, while simultaneously paying attention to the larger questions of diachronic preservation and non-preservation of dative. We suggest that our findings have interesting ramifications for the categorization of case as structural and non-structural in generative grammar.


  • ‘Hungering and Lusting for Women and Fleshly Delicacies’: Reconstructing Grammatical Relations for Proto‐Germanic*

    by Jóhanna Barđdal, Thórhallur Eythórsson

    Syntactic reconstruction has long been virtually outlawed in historical‐comparative research, more or less ever since Watkins’s influential works on the problems of reconstructing word order for Proto‐Indo‐European. Recently, through the emergence of Construction Grammar, where complex syntactic structures are regarded as form–function pairings, a resurgence of syntactic reconstruction is made possible, as complex syntactic structures become a legitimate object of the Comparative Method. Given the legitimacy of syntactic reconstruction, and hence the possible reconstruction of argument‐structure constructions, a major question arises as to whether grammatical relations are also reconstructable for earlier undocumented language periods. We argue that if the constructions singling out grammatical relations can be reconstructed for a proto‐branch, the grammatical relations following from these are also reconstructable for that proto‐branch. In order to illustrate our methodology, we show how a reconstruction of the subject function in Proto‐Germanic may be carried out, more specifically of oblique‐subject predicates like ‘hunger’, ‘thirst’ and ‘lust’, based on the subject properties found in the earliest Germanic daughter languages.