JKJoel S. Karp

Joel S. Karp

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article

Previous Organizations / Institutes

The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years


Joel S. Karp has a total of 85 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • A Virtual Clinical Trial to Detect Changes in Tumor Uptake With PET Using Lesion Embedding

    by Majid Kazemi Kozani, Min Gao, Joel S. Karp, Suleman Surti

    We conducted a virtual clinical trial (VCT) using patient data from the PennPET Explorer scanner and embedded lesions to model tumor response to therapy as measured by a change in the standardized uptake value (SUV). Two patient data sets (high and low BMI) were bootstrapped prior to embedding data from separately acquired sphere-in-air data sets. In each bootstrapped dataset, 20 small lesions (1 cm diameter) were embedded, 10 each in lung and liver organs. Multiple scans were reconstructed using list-mode time of flight-ordered subset expectation maximization (TOF-OSEM) for varying scan durations and pre-defined lesion uptake values. The resulting SUV measurements were utilized to construct receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curves to evaluate the system’s ability to discriminate between different values of lesion uptake corresponding to therapy-induced changes. The area under the ROC curve (AUC) was used as a summary metric of this discrimination performance. Our results demonstrate that long axial field of view (LAFOV) PET scanners with high sensitivity may effectively detect early tumor response to therapy, even with brief scan durations (1 minute scan) or, equivalently, with reduced activity. The AUC values change very slowly with increasing scan duration, suggesting that performance is not primarily limited by count statistics within the studied range. The AUC values are also not very sensitive to the patient BMI or the type of SUV metrics (i.e. 𝐒𝐔𝐕𝐦𝐞𝐚𝐧 and 𝐒𝐔𝐕𝐦𝐚𝐱), and are relatively independent of the local background (organ) uptake. The primary factor determining the AUC values seems to be the absolute change in lesion uptake that will be sensitive to partial volume effects as determined by the scanner spatial resolution. Hence, a standard axial field-of-view scanner with similar spatial resolution will likely perform as well as a LAFOV scanner after appropriate compensation for the sensitivity differences.

  • Impact of Detector Parameters and Image Resolution Modeling on Dedicated Brain PET Imaging

    by Min Gao, Samuel Matej, Joel S. Karp, Suleman Surti

    High performance brain PET scanners suitable for accurate and precise measurement of uptake in small regions of the brain require high spatial resolution (1.5–2 mm) together with high system sensitivity. While small cross section crystals are needed to achieve high spatial resolution with pixelated detectors, effective system sensitivity requires long crystals and good time-of-flight (TOF) resolution. In addition, depending on crystal thickness, some level of depth-of-interaction (DOI) capability may also be needed to reduce parallax error. While various methods for DOI measurement can be utilized within the detector, the impact on reconstructed spatial resolution as a function of crystal thickness needs to be carefully evaluated. The focus of this work is to use Monte Carlo simulations to evaluate the impact of crystal size, thickness, and DOI resolution on the reconstructed spatial resolution in a high-resolution brain scanner design. Two crystal cross sections were chosen, 1.6 mm 1.6 mm and 2 mm 2 mm, and three different LSO crystal thickness (10 mm, 15 mm, and 20 mm) were evaluated. We evaluated these system designs without DOI capability and with DOI resolution (4–12 mm) for varying crystal thickness. In addition, we evaluated the use of image-space resolution modeling (IRM) techniques, which can mitigate losses in spatial resolution and positioning accuracy due to parallax error and Compton scatter, and to complement the advantages of DOI capability. A brain size elliptical phantom with small spheres was simulated to study the overall benefit in uptake measurements for small objects using the contrast recovery coefficient (CRC) metric. Our results show that a system with 2 mm 2 mm crystals can provide comparable image quality in terms of CRC measurement than one with 1.6 mm 1.6 mm crystals. However, crystal thickness has a bigger impact on spatial resolution and CRC with performance degrading with best performance achieved with 10 mm thick crystals. DOI measurement is necessary with longer crystals in order to maintain good imaging performance with high sensitivity. For the 15 mm thick crystals 9 mm DOI resolution is needed to compensate for the loss in spatial resolution compared to 10 mm thick crystals without DOI, but still with lower CRC. A similar conclusion is reached for 20 mm crystals with 4 mm DOI resolution. Alternatively, IRM methods can provide improved and similar performance for all crystal thicknesses studied here, indicating a pathway for achieving our brain scanner design goals without additional cost, complexity, and performance tradeoffs. This work provides a systematic investigation for designing future brain PET systems.


  • Randoms Estimation for Long Axial Field-of-View PET

    by Margaret E. Daube-Witherspoon, Stephen C. Moore, Joel S. Karp

    The high sensitivity of long axial field-of-view (AFOV) PET scanners has enabled studies over a wide range of count rates and count densities. However, these systems have a large axial acceptance angle that necessitates a wide coincidence window to capture the oblique true coincidences. In addition, the measured delays sinogram is sparse and noisy. We studied four methods of randoms estimation on a long AFOV system to assess their impact on accuracy and image noise: measured delays using a delayed coincidence window (RD), 2D Casey averaging of measured delays (RD-smooth), 2D average of measured delays (RD-ave – the current default method on the PennPET Explorer), and estimation of randoms from singles (RS). We looked at cases with varying count densities, randoms fractions, and non-pure positron emitters. A positive bias observed at low randoms counts for the RD and RD-smooth methods was not seen with the RD-ave or RS methods. For all cases, quantitative results with RS agreed to within 2.5% of the RD-ave method, while RD and RD-smooth estimates showed differences of 5-49%, with larger differences in areas of low uptake. The RS method is a practical technique for list-mode data and list-mode reconstruction by reducing the size of stored list events. It also avoids small approximations in the RDave method. For long AFOV systems, estimating randoms from singles is a practical and accurate method.

  • Open Access

    Depth-of-interaction encoding techniques for pixelated PET detectors enabled by machine learning methods and fast waveform digitization

    by Bing Dai, Srilalan Krishnamoorthy, Emmanuel Morales, Suleman Surti, Joel S Karp

    Objective. Pixelated detectors with single-ended readout are routinely used by commercial positron emission tomography scanners owing to their good energy and timing resolution and optimized manufacturing, but they typically do not provide depth-of-interaction (DOI) information, which can help improve the performance of systems with higher resolution and smaller ring diameter. This work aims to develop a technique for multi-level DOI classification that does not require modifications to the detector designs. Approach. We leveraged high-speed (5 Gs s−1) waveform sampling electronics with the Domino Ring Sampler (DRS4) and machine learning (ML) methods to extract DOI information from the entire scintillation waveforms of pixelated crystals. We evaluated different grouping schemes for multi-level DOI classification by analyzing the DOI positioning profile and DOI positioning error. We examined trade-offs among crystal configurations, detector timing performance, and DOI classification accuracy. We also investigated the impact of different ML algorithms and input features—extracted from scintillation waveforms—on model accuracy. Main results. The DOI positioning profile and positioning error suggest that 2- or 3-level binning was effective for 20 mm long crystals. 2-level discrete DOI models achieved 95% class-wise accuracy and 83% overall accuracy in positioning events into the correct DOI level and 3-level up to 90% class-wise accuracy for long and narrow crystals (2 × 2 × 20 mm3). Long short-term memory networks trained with time–frequency moments were twice as efficient in training time while maintaining equal or better accuracy compared to those trained with waveforms. Classical ML algorithms exhibit comparable accuracy while consuming one order less training time than deep learning models. Significance. This work demonstrates a proof-of-concept approach for obtaining DOI information from commercially available pixelated detectors without altering the detector design thereby avoiding potential degradation in detector timing performance. It provides an alternative solution for multi-level DOI classification, potentially inspiring future scanner designs.


  • Open Access

    Impact of deep learning denoising on kinetic modelling for low-dose dynamic PET: application to single- and dual-tracer imaging protocols

    by Florence M. Muller, Elizabeth J. Li, Margaret E. Daube-Witherspoon, Austin R. Pantel, Corinde E. Wiers, Jacob G. Dubroff, Christian Vanhove, Stefaan Vandenberghe, Joel S. Karp

    Purpose: Long-axial field-of-view PET scanners capture multi-organ tracer distribution with high sensitivity, enabling lower dose dynamic protocols and dual-tracer imaging for comprehensive disease characterization. However, reducing dose may compromise data quality and time-activity curve (TAC) fitting, leading to higher bias in kinetic parameters. Parametric imaging poses further challenges due to noise amplification in voxel-based modelling. We explore the potential of deep learning denoising (DL-DN) to improve quantification for low-dose dynamic PET. Methods: Using 16 [18F]FDG PET studies from the PennPET Explorer, we trained a DL framework on 10-min images from late-phase uptake (static data) that were sub-sampled from 1/2 to 1/300 of the counts. This model was used to denoise early-to-late dynamic frame images. Its impact on quantification was evaluated using compartmental modelling and voxel-based graphical analysis for parametric imaging for single- and dual-tracer dynamic studies with [18F]FDG and [18F]FGln at original (injected) and reduced (sub-sampled) doses. Quantification differences were evaluated for the area under the curve of TACs, Ki for [18F]FDG and VT for [18F]FGln, and parametric images. Results: DL-DN consistently improved image quality across all dynamic frames, systematically enhancing TAC consistency and reducing tissue-dependent bias and variability in Ki and VT down to 40 MBq doses. DL-DN preserved tumor heterogeneity in Logan VT images and delineation of high-flux regions in Patlak Ki maps. In a /[18F]FDG dual-tracer study, bias trends aligned with single-tracer results but showed reduced accuracy for [¹⁸F]FGln in breast lesions at very low doses (4 MBq). Conclusion: This study demonstrates that applying DL-DN trained on static [18F]FDG PET images to dynamic [18F]FDG and [18F]FGln PET can permit significantly reduced doses, preserving accurate FDG Ki and FGln VT measurements, and enhancing parametric image quality. DL-DN shows promise for improving dynamic PET quantification at reduced doses, including novel dual-tracer studies.


  • Zynq SoM Readout for PET Imaging, for HEP Data Acquisition, and for Prototype PCBs

    by W. J. Ashmanskas, E. Chong, M.A. Ramirez, P. Keener, S. Krishnamoorthy, E. Morales, A. Nikolica, S. Surti, J. S. Karp, J. Klein, et al.

    We describe our experience using several commerical system-on-module (SoM) daughter boards (MicroZed, Z-turn, Mercury XU5), based on the Zynq system-on-chip platform, for control and readout of 8 custom Printed Circuit Board (PCB) designs, both for Time-of-Flight Positron Emission Tomography (TOF-PET) and for High Energy Physics (HEP). SoMs are a convenient and powerful solution to interface custom PCBs to gigabit Ethernet for data acquisition. We use this approach for 3 PET-readout PCBs (MRB2, MCU, ROCSTAR, for readout of TOF-PET whole-body and dedicated breast scanners) and for 5 HEP designs (OCB, TP, PTC, AMAC tester, Q-Pix ASIC tester), which we briefly describe.The Zynq's hybrid nature (FPGA fabic woven to ARM CPU) facilitates a wide range of readout tasks. The SoMs offer 100+ FPGA-driven I/O pins for interfacing one's custom PCB, and integrate FPGA logic, CPU, 1GB+ SDRAM, gigabit Ethernet, DC/DC converters, and flash memory for power-on configuration. For small projects, such as our MCU and various ASIC-testing boards, the SoM eliminates the PCB engineering effort to integrate an FPGA and its power network. For larger projects, such as our ROCSTAR and MRB2, the SoM configures, controls, and intelligently networks our custom PCB's larger FPGA. In our experience, the SoM's embedded Linux environment straightforwardly facilitates power-up, configuration, firmware/software updates, networked register-file access, basic readout, and highly convenient remote control via Jupyter notebooks. Sustained gigabit readout via Direct Memory Access (DMA) has required more effort. With a fully-user-space approach (no device driver), we have sustained ~ 300 Mbit/s readout from FPGA to network. We describe both the unconventional user-space approach and a more conventional approach using a DMA device driver. We provide a pedagogical example of high-speed readout, both to stimulate discussion and to facilitate future applications.


  • Open Access

    Performance evaluation of the PennPET explorer with expanded axial coverage

    by Bing Dai, Margaret E Daube-Witherspoon, Stephen McDonald, Matthew E Werner, Michael J Parma, Michael J Geagan, Varsha Viswanath, Joel S Karp

    Objective. This work evaluated the updated PennPET Explorer total-body (TB) PET scanner, which was extended to 6 rings with updated readout firmware to achieve a 142 cm axial field of view (AFOV) without 7.6 cm inter-ring axial gaps. Approach. National Electrical Manufacturers Association (NEMA) NU 2-2018 measurements were performed with modifications including longer phantoms for sensitivity and count-rate measurements and additional positions for spatial resolution and image quality. A long uniform phantom and the clinical trials network (CTN) phantom were also used. Main results. The total sensitivity increased to 140 kcps MBq−1 for a 70 cm line, a gain of 1.8x compared to the same system with axial gaps; an additional 47% increase in total counts was observed with a 142 cm line at the same activity per cm. The noise equivalent count rate (NECR) increased by 1.8x without axial gaps. The peak NECR is 1550 kcps at 25 kBq cc−1 for a 140 cm phantom; due to increased randoms, the NECR is lower than with a 70 cm phantom, for which NECR is 2156 kcps cc−1 at 25 kBq cc−1 and continues increasing. The time-of-flight resolution is 250 ps, increasing by 18F and 89Zr. Significance. The performance evaluation of the updated PennPET Explorer demonstrates significant gains compared to conventional scanners and shows where the current NEMA standard needs to be updated for TB-PET systems. The comparisons of systems with and without inter-ring gaps demonstrate the performance trade-offs of a more cost-effective TB-PET system with incomplete detector coverage.


  • Total-body PET: a new paradigm for molecular imaging

    by Margaret E Daube-Witherspoon, Austin R Pantel, Daniel A Pryma, Joel S Karp

    Total body (TB) positron emission tomography (PET) instruments have dramatically changed the paradigm of PET clinical and research studies due to their very high sensitivity and capability to image dynamic radiopharmaceutical distributions in the major organs of the body simultaneously. In this manuscript, we review the design of these systems and discuss general challenges and trade-offs to maximize the performance gains of current TB-PET systems. We then describe new concepts and technology that may impact future TB-PET systems. The manuscript summarizes what has been learned from the initial sites with TB-PET and explores potential research and clinical applications of TB-PET. The current generation of TB-PET systems range in axial field-of-view (AFOV) from 1 to 2 m and serve to illustrate the benefits and opportunities of a longer AFOV for various applications in PET. In only a few years of use these new TB-PET systems have shown that they will play an important role in expanding the field of molecular imaging and benefiting clinical practice.


  • The potential of a medium-cost long axial FOV PET system for nuclear medicine departments

    by Stefaan Vandenberghe, Nicolas A. Karakatsanis, Maya Abi Akl, Jens Maebe, Suleman Surti, Rudi A. Dierckx, Daniel A. Pryma, Sadek A. Nehmeh, Othmane Bouhali, Joel S. Karp

    Purpose Total body positron emission tomography (TB-PET) has recently been introduced in nuclear medicine departments. There is a large interest in these systems, but for many centers, the high acquisition cost makes it very difficult to justify their current operational budget. Here, we propose medium-cost long axial FOV scanners as an alternative. Methods Several medium-cost long axial FOV designs are described with their advantages and drawbacks. We describe their potential for higher throughput, more cost-effective scanning, a larger group of indications, and novel research opportunities. The wider spread of TB-PET can also lead to the fast introduction of new tracers (at a low dose), new methodologies, and optimized workflows. Conclusions A medium-cost TB-PET would be positioned between the current standard PET-CT and the full TB-PET systems in investment but recapitulate most advantages of full TB-PET. These systems could be more easily justified financially in a standard academic or large private nuclear medicine department and still have ample research options.