CKCarl Henrik Knutsen

Carl Henrik Knutsen

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Carl Henrik Knutsen has a total of 60 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Executive constraints and focal points: factors facilitating democratic breakdowns led by incumbents versus non-incumbents, 1789–2020

    by Vilde Lunnan Djuve, Carl Henrik Knutsen, Jonas Willibald Schmid, Svend-Erik Skaaning

  • Open Access

    Land, Politics, and Development

    by Carl Henrik Knutsen

    In this article, I review and discuss Michael Albertus' recent book Land Power, which highlights how patterns of landownership and different policies pertaining to land influence various outcomes of great importance, including racial hierarchies, gender inequality, environmental degradation, political institutions, and economic development. Considering case studies from different regions and historical periods, Albertus convincingly shows how the distribution and regulation of landownership can contribute to lock countries into persistent states of low development, autocratic rule, and inegalitarian distributions of power and economic opportunities. Yet, he also shows how specific, well-designed policies pertaining to land may help countries break out of such situations. After reviewing the book, I discuss lessons from Land Power for the wider scholarly literature on comparative development. I do so by first addressing the “great divergence” question of why some countries develop and experience benevolent societal outcomes whereas others stagnate and experience less benevolent outcomes. Second, I discuss the question of “getting to Denmark”: what policies and reforms can be put in place, and under what conditions, to set countries off on a benevolent, developmental path? I end the article with some considerations and implications for future research, especially discussing how big-picture narrative books such as Land Power and more focused empirical studies both may fruitfully inform scholars to push the knowledge frontier on comparative development.

  • Open Access

    Model Spaces in Crossnational Research: The Case of Democracy and Growth

    by Andrés Cruz, John Gerring, Carl Henrik Knutsen

    Knowledge cumulation is notoriously hard in crossnational research. Despite mostly sharing observational units and data sources, studies differ in myriad details that hinder comparability. Attempts to learn directly from published estimates—as in meta-analysis—must grapple with publication bias, p-hacking, disparate methodologies, and overlapping samples. We propose to construct and analyze model spaces: combinations of design choices appearing in published baseline or robustness-check models. Analyzing a literature's model space identifies the design choices that most strongly drive results, narrowing the range of potential disagreements and focusing discussions on what is most consequential. As an illustration, we present and analyze model spaces for the democracy-growth literature, showcasing the importance of (some) design choices and suggesting new research avenues.

  • Top Cited Papers
    Open Access

    The effects of government propaganda in electoral authoritarian regimes: Evidence from Turkey

    by Philipp M. Lutscher, Jonas Bergan Draege, Carl Henrik Knutsen

    Previous research conducted in closed autocracies indicates that government propaganda can deter opposition, shift political attitudes, and influence emotions. Yet the specific mechanisms and contextual factors influencing how and when propaganda works remain unclear. We theorize how power-projecting government propaganda works differently for government supporters and opponents in polarized electoral authoritarian regimes, focusing on emotional reactions, sense of societal belonging, and downstream effects on contentious political behavior. Through two preregistered surveys in Turkey ( N = 6,286), we find that supporters exposed to propaganda videos feel a greater sense of belonging and are more susceptible to engage in pro-government activities. Opponents report heightened anger and anxiety and seem deterred from protesting. However, the latter effect weakened during the highly contested 2023 electoral campaign. These results indicate that propaganda can help electoral authoritarian regimes deter anti-government action and encourage pro-government action, but that its deterrent effects may weaken during periods of high mobilization and contention.


  • Open Access

    The Effects of Government Propaganda in Electoral Authoritarian Regimes: Evidence from Turkey

    by Philipp Lutscher, Jonas Dræge, Carl Henrik Knutsen

    Previous research conducted in closed autocracies indicates that government propaganda can deter opposition, shift political attitudes, and influence emotions. Yet the specific mechanisms and contextual factors influencing how and when propaganda works remain unclear. We theorize how power-projecting government propaganda works differently for government supporters and opponents in polarized electoral authoritarian regimes, focusing on emotional reactions, sense of societal belonging, and downstream effects on contentious political behavior. Through two pre-registered surveys in Turkey (N=6,286), we find that supporters exposed to propaganda videos feel greater sense of belonging and are more susceptible to engage in pro-government activities. Opponents report heightened anger and anxiety and seem deterred from protesting. However, the latter effect weakened during the highly contested 2023 electoral campaign. These results indicate that propaganda can help electoral authoritarian regimes deter anti-government action and encourage pro-government action, but that its deterrent effects may weaken during periods of high mobilization and contention.

  • Open Access

    Enhancing Transparency and Replicability in Data Collection: Lessons from the Construction of Three Education Datasets

    by Adrián Del Río, Woseeok Kim, Carl Henrik Knutsen, Anja Neundorf, Agustina S. Paglayan, Eugenia Nazrullaeva

    Assembling datasets is crucial for advancing social science research, but researchers who construct datasets often face difficult decisions with little guidance. Once public, these datasets are sometimes used without proper consideration of their creators’ choices and how these affect the validity of inferences. To support both data creators and data users, we discuss the strengths, limitations, and implications of various data collection methodologies and strategies, showing how seemingly trivial methodological differences can significantly impact conclusions. The lessons we distill build on the process of constructing three cross-national datasets on education systems. Despite their common focus, these datasets differ in the dimensions they measure, as well as their definitions of key concepts, coding thresholds and other assumptions, types of coders, and sources. From these lessons, we develop and propose general guidelines for dataset creators and users aimed at enhancing transparency, replicability, and valid inferences in the social sciences.


  • Open Access

    Paths to Power: A New Dataset on the Social Profile of Governments

    by Jacob Nyrup, Carl Henrik Knutsen, Peter Egge Langsæther, Ina Lyftingsmo Kristiansen

    Systematized information on the background of policymakers across long time-periods and all geographical regions of the world remains limited. In this article, we introduce Paths to Power (PtP), a new dataset on the educational, occupational, and social background of cabinet members. PtP contains detailed individual-level data – whenever identifiable – on 44,789 cabinet members across 141 countries in the period 1966-2021. This comprehensive dataset will be of relevance to numerous scholars (and others) interested in understanding politics and recent political history, and it enables a wide variety of new, empirically founded insights. We first present how the data is created and then discuss data quality and limitations. Next, we show how PtP is useful for researchers in diverse fields, including comparative politics, political sociology, gender studies, public administration, and international relations.


  • Open Access

    Mass Mobilization in the Modern Era: Introducing the Opposition Movements and Groups (OMG) Dataset, 1789–2019

    by Marianne Dahl, Sirianne Dahlum, Hanne Fjelde, Haakon Gjerløw, Carl Henrik Knutsen, Carina Strøm-Sedgwick, Tore Wig

    The nature and consequences of mass mobilization are core topics in the social sciences. How have mass mobilization movements evolved over time? How do key characteristics of such movements, including their social composition or ideology, influence their ability to overthrow or alter political institutions? We introduce the Opposition Movements and Groups (OMG) dataset, which – due to its unique contents and extensive coverage – will help researchers to better address these and many other questions about mass mobilization movements. OMG includes information on the stated goals, duration, size, tactics, ideology, and social and organizational composition of 1452 mass mobilization movements, globally, from 1789 to 2019. We discuss OMG’s contents, construction, validity and reliability issues, and how it complements existing datasets. We showcase the data, first, by documenting several key trends in movement characteristics since the French Revolution, and, second, by shedding new light on the much-discussed relationship between nonviolent movements and democratization.