René van Woudenberg
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Previous Organizations / Institutes
The organizations / institutes from the scholar's other articles in the past ten years
Research Subjects
René van Woudenberg has a total of 17 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
- Jeroen de Ridder
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
5 shared publications - Iris Maria Lechner
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
3 shared publications - Lex M. Bouter
Amsterdam University Medical Centers
3 shared publications - Rik Peels
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam
3 shared publications - Chris Ranalli
Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, Netherlands
2 shared publications - Joeri K. Tijdink
Department Ethics, Law and Humanities, Amsterdam UMC location Vrije Universiteit Amsterdam, Amsterdam, The Netherlands
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 13 October 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Social Epistemology
- Vol. 40 (2) , 214-228
The University, Epistemic Power, and Institutional Epistemic Responsibilities
- 13 October 2025
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Social Epistemology
- Vol. 40 (2) , 214-228
Open AccessThe University, Epistemic Power, and Institutional Epistemic Responsibilities
- Open Access
- 24 November 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Policy Reviews in Higher Education
- Vol. 9 (1) , 7-31
Development of practical tools to realize the epistemic responsibilities of universities: a co-design study
- 24 November 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Policy Reviews in Higher Education
- Vol. 9 (1) , 7-31
Open AccessDevelopment of practical tools to realize the epistemic responsibilities of universities: a co-design study
- 17 May 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 22-28
The Metaphysics of Progress
A conceptual analysis of “progress” makes clear that progress is always relativized to certain respects, or properties that admit of degrees (“gradable properties”). What is an embodiment of progress in one respect can be an instance of regress in another. Moreover, since progress occurs over time, it presupposes that time is real and that atemporal entities (e.g. numbers) cannot make progress. Even though there is a general concept of progress (that allows for phrases such as “the cancer is progressing”), we usually think of progress in a more specific sense, viz. as signalling a development in a direction which we positively value. Thus, this specific concept of progress presupposes that values are real.
- 17 May 2024
- Published by Taylor & Francis
- p. 22-28
The Metaphysics of Progress
A conceptual analysis of “progress” makes clear that progress is always relativized to certain respects, or properties that admit of degrees (“gradable properties”). What is an embodiment of progress in one respect can be an instance of regress in another. Moreover, since progress occurs over time, it presupposes that time is real and that atemporal entities (e.g. numbers) cannot make progress. Even though there is a general concept of progress (that allows for phrases such as “the cancer is progressing”), we usually think of progress in a more specific sense, viz. as signalling a development in a direction which we positively value. Thus, this specific concept of progress presupposes that values are real.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 26 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Philosophy & Technology
- Vol. 37 (1) , 1-26
Authorship and ChatGPT: a Conservative View
Is ChatGPT an author? Given its capacity to generate something that reads like human-written text in response to prompts, it might seem natural to ascribe authorship to ChatGPT. However, we argue that ChatGPT is not an author. ChatGPT fails to meet the criteria of authorship because it lacks the ability to perform illocutionary speech acts such as promising or asserting, lacks the fitting mental states like knowledge, belief, or intention, and cannot take responsibility for the texts it produces. Three perspectives are compared: liberalism (which ascribes authorship to ChatGPT), conservatism (which denies ChatGPT's authorship for normative and metaphysical reasons), and moderatism (which treats ChatGPT as if it possesses authorship without committing to the existence of mental states like knowledge, belief, or intention). We conclude that conservatism provides a more nuanced understanding of authorship in AI than liberalism and moderatism, without denying the significant potential, influence, or utility of AI technologies such as ChatGPT.
- 26 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in Philosophy & Technology
- Vol. 37 (1) , 1-26
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessAuthorship and ChatGPT: a Conservative View
Is ChatGPT an author? Given its capacity to generate something that reads like human-written text in response to prompts, it might seem natural to ascribe authorship to ChatGPT. However, we argue that ChatGPT is not an author. ChatGPT fails to meet the criteria of authorship because it lacks the ability to perform illocutionary speech acts such as promising or asserting, lacks the fitting mental states like knowledge, belief, or intention, and cannot take responsibility for the texts it produces. Three perspectives are compared: liberalism (which ascribes authorship to ChatGPT), conservatism (which denies ChatGPT's authorship for normative and metaphysical reasons), and moderatism (which treats ChatGPT as if it possesses authorship without committing to the existence of mental states like knowledge, belief, or intention). We conclude that conservatism provides a more nuanced understanding of authorship in AI than liberalism and moderatism, without denying the significant potential, influence, or utility of AI technologies such as ChatGPT.
- 1 November 2023
- Published by The Pennsylvania State University Press in Victorians Institute Journal
- Vol. 50, 29-53
John Ruskin on Reading
Victorians read a lot, and they reflected on reading: Why read? What to read? Reading to what goal? After some stage setting, this article discusses four of John Ruskin’s thoughts on reading as expounded in Sesame and Lilies (1865) and that have never received much attention. (1) There are two species of books, “books of the hour” and “books of all time.” (2) The selection of which books to read is an ethical matter. (3) The norm for reading that readers should aim to comply with is the author’s meaning. (4) Readers should love the authors they are reading in order to understand them truly. This article discusses these claims and argues for a qualified endorsement of (1) in favor of (2), argues that (3) constitutes the commonsense view of reading, and defends it against various criticisms. The article finally argues against (4).
- 1 November 2023
- Published by The Pennsylvania State University Press in Victorians Institute Journal
- Vol. 50, 29-53
John Ruskin on Reading
Victorians read a lot, and they reflected on reading: Why read? What to read? Reading to what goal? After some stage setting, this article discusses four of John Ruskin’s thoughts on reading as expounded in Sesame and Lilies (1865) and that have never received much attention. (1) There are two species of books, “books of the hour” and “books of all time.” (2) The selection of which books to read is an ethical matter. (3) The norm for reading that readers should aim to comply with is the author’s meaning. (4) Readers should love the authors they are reading in order to understand them truly. This article discusses these claims and argues for a qualified endorsement of (1) in favor of (2), argues that (3) constitutes the commonsense view of reading, and defends it against various criticisms. The article finally argues against (4).
- Open Access
- 11 September 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Accountability in Research
- Vol. 32 (2) , 99-119
The core epistemic responsibilities of universities: Results from a Delphi study
Epistemic responsibilities (ERs) of universities concern equipping and empowering its researchers, educators and students to attain, produce, exchange and disseminate knowledge. ERs can potentially guide universities in improving education, research and in service to society. Building on earlier philosophical work, we applied empirical methods to identify core ERs of universities and their constituting elements. We used a three-round Delphi survey, alternating between closed questions to gain consensus, and open questions to let panelists motivate their answers. 46 panelists participated in our study. We reached consensus on six ERs: 1) to foster research integrity, 2) to stimulate the development of intellectual virtues, 3) to address the big questions of life, 4) to cultivate the diversity of the disciplinary fields, 5) to serve and engage with society at large, and 6) to cultivate and safeguard academic freedom. Together the six ERs contain 27 elements. Consensus rates ranged from 73%-100% for both the ERs and their elements. Participants' detailed responses led to substantial improvements in the accompanying descriptions of the ERs. Our findings can inform the debate about the roles and responsibilities of universities, and inform researchers and policy makers to emphasize epistemic tasks of universities.
- 11 September 2023
- Published by Taylor & Francis in Accountability in Research
- Vol. 32 (2) , 99-119
Open AccessThe core epistemic responsibilities of universities: Results from a Delphi study
Epistemic responsibilities (ERs) of universities concern equipping and empowering its researchers, educators and students to attain, produce, exchange and disseminate knowledge. ERs can potentially guide universities in improving education, research and in service to society. Building on earlier philosophical work, we applied empirical methods to identify core ERs of universities and their constituting elements. We used a three-round Delphi survey, alternating between closed questions to gain consensus, and open questions to let panelists motivate their answers. 46 panelists participated in our study. We reached consensus on six ERs: 1) to foster research integrity, 2) to stimulate the development of intellectual virtues, 3) to address the big questions of life, 4) to cultivate the diversity of the disciplinary fields, 5) to serve and engage with society at large, and 6) to cultivate and safeguard academic freedom. Together the six ERs contain 27 elements. Consensus rates ranged from 73%-100% for both the ERs and their elements. Participants' detailed responses led to substantial improvements in the accompanying descriptions of the ERs. Our findings can inform the debate about the roles and responsibilities of universities, and inform researchers and policy makers to emphasize epistemic tasks of universities.
- Open Access
- 6 April 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Foundations of Science
- Vol. 30 (1) , 55-72
Non-causal Explanations in the Humanities: Some Examples
The humanistic disciplines aim to offer explanations of a wide variety of phenomena. Philosophical theories of explanation have focused mostly on explanations in the natural sciences; a much discussed theory of explanation is the causal theory of explanation. Recently it has come to be recognized that the sciences sometimes offer respectable explanations that are non-causal. This paper broadens the discussion by discussing explanations that are offered in the fields of history, linguistics, literary theory, and archaeology that do not seem to fit the causal theory of explanation. We conducted an exploratory survey in acclaimed humanities textbooks to find explicitly so-called explanations and analyze their nature. The survey suggests that non-causal explanations are an integral part of the humanities and that they are of distinct kinds. This paper describes three kinds that are suggested by our survey: teleological, formal, and normative explanations. We suggest that such humanistic explanations strengthen the case for explanatory pluralism.
- 6 April 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Foundations of Science
- Vol. 30 (1) , 55-72
Open AccessNon-causal Explanations in the Humanities: Some Examples
The humanistic disciplines aim to offer explanations of a wide variety of phenomena. Philosophical theories of explanation have focused mostly on explanations in the natural sciences; a much discussed theory of explanation is the causal theory of explanation. Recently it has come to be recognized that the sciences sometimes offer respectable explanations that are non-causal. This paper broadens the discussion by discussing explanations that are offered in the fields of history, linguistics, literary theory, and archaeology that do not seem to fit the causal theory of explanation. We conducted an exploratory survey in acclaimed humanities textbooks to find explicitly so-called explanations and analyze their nature. The survey suggests that non-causal explanations are an integral part of the humanities and that they are of distinct kinds. This paper describes three kinds that are suggested by our survey: teleological, formal, and normative explanations. We suggest that such humanistic explanations strengthen the case for explanatory pluralism.
- Open Access
- 13 March 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Interdisciplinary Science Reviews
- Vol. 48 (2) , 411-426
Argumentative strategies against scientism: an overview
This paper presents and discusses various strategies that have been wielded against scientism, roughly the claim that only science can give us knowledge. The strategies identified are: (1) the counter example strategy, (2) the denying of claimed entailments of science strategy, (3) the self-undermining strategy, (4) the presupposition strategy, and (5) the limits of science strategy. In addition, two proposals are discussed that aim to recast the debate about scientism in a way that renders these strategies obsolete. It is argued that these proposals are misguided.
- 13 March 2023
- Published by SAGE Publications in Interdisciplinary Science Reviews
- Vol. 48 (2) , 411-426
Open AccessArgumentative strategies against scientism: an overview
This paper presents and discusses various strategies that have been wielded against scientism, roughly the claim that only science can give us knowledge. The strategies identified are: (1) the counter example strategy, (2) the denying of claimed entailments of science strategy, (3) the self-undermining strategy, (4) the presupposition strategy, and (5) the limits of science strategy. In addition, two proposals are discussed that aim to recast the debate about scientism in a way that renders these strategies obsolete. It is argued that these proposals are misguided.
- Open Access
- 19 May 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal for General Philosophy of Science
- Vol. 52 (4) , 543-561
Explanations of Research Misconduct, and How They Hang Together
In this paper, we explore different possible explanations for research misconduct (especially falsification and fabrication), and investigate whether they are compatible. We suggest that to explain research misconduct, we should pay attention to three factors: (1) the beliefs and desires of the misconductor, (2) contextual affordances, (3) and unconscious biases or influences. We draw on the three different narratives (individual, institutional, system of science) of research misconduct as proposed by Sovacool to review six different explanations. Four theories start from the individual: Rational Choice theory, Bad Apple theory, General Strain Theory and Prospect Theory. Organizational Justice Theory focuses on institutional factors, while New Public Management targets the system of science. For each theory, we illustrate the kinds of facts that must be known in order for explanations based on them to have minimal plausibility. We suggest that none can constitute a full explanation. Finally, we explore how the different possible explanations interrelate. We find that they are compatible, with the exception of explanations based on Rational Choice Theory and Prospect Theory respectively, which are incompatible with one another. For illustrative purposes we examine the case of Diederik Stapel.
- 19 May 2021
- Published by Springer Nature in Journal for General Philosophy of Science
- Vol. 52 (4) , 543-561
Open AccessExplanations of Research Misconduct, and How They Hang Together
In this paper, we explore different possible explanations for research misconduct (especially falsification and fabrication), and investigate whether they are compatible. We suggest that to explain research misconduct, we should pay attention to three factors: (1) the beliefs and desires of the misconductor, (2) contextual affordances, (3) and unconscious biases or influences. We draw on the three different narratives (individual, institutional, system of science) of research misconduct as proposed by Sovacool to review six different explanations. Four theories start from the individual: Rational Choice theory, Bad Apple theory, General Strain Theory and Prospect Theory. Organizational Justice Theory focuses on institutional factors, while New Public Management targets the system of science. For each theory, we illustrate the kinds of facts that must be known in order for explanations based on them to have minimal plausibility. We suggest that none can constitute a full explanation. Finally, we explore how the different possible explanations interrelate. We find that they are compatible, with the exception of explanations based on Rational Choice Theory and Prospect Theory respectively, which are incompatible with one another. For illustrative purposes we examine the case of Diederik Stapel.
- Open Access
- 6 July 2020
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 8, 862
Academia’s Big Five: a normative taxonomy for the epistemic responsibilities of universities
This paper proposes a normative taxonomy by which universities can express the extent to which they meet five core epistemic responsibilities. Epistemic responsibilities are responsibilities that have to do with the attainment of knowledge and understanding. The core epistemic responsibilities, which we call the Big Five, are to (1) foster research integrity, (2) teach for intellectual virtue, (3) address the big questions of life, (4) give humanistic inquiry and education a proper place, and (5) serve society. The paper characterizes the Big Five in some detail and explains why they are core epistemic responsibilities of universities. The paper concludes by describing the steps that should be taken in order to test, amend, and implement the taxonomy.
- 6 July 2020
- Published by F1000 Research Ltd in F1000Research
- Vol. 8, 862
Open AccessAcademia’s Big Five: a normative taxonomy for the epistemic responsibilities of universities
This paper proposes a normative taxonomy by which universities can express the extent to which they meet five core epistemic responsibilities. Epistemic responsibilities are responsibilities that have to do with the attainment of knowledge and understanding. The core epistemic responsibilities, which we call the Big Five, are to (1) foster research integrity, (2) teach for intellectual virtue, (3) address the big questions of life, (4) give humanistic inquiry and education a proper place, and (5) serve society. The paper characterizes the Big Five in some detail and explains why they are core epistemic responsibilities of universities. The paper concludes by describing the steps that should be taken in order to test, amend, and implement the taxonomy.