Adam Nulty
Current Organizations / Institutes
The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article
Research Subjects
Adam Nulty has a total of 10 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Chris Lefkaditis
Hellesdon Dental Care, 153 Middleton’s Lane, Norwich, NR6 5SF, UK
3 shared publicationsQuintus Van Tonder
Zandielle Clinic, Queen’s Square, Attleborough, NR17 2AE, UK
3 shared publications- Ashtyn Hoffer
International Digital Dental Academy, Norwich NR14 8FB, UK
2 shared publications - Cameron Kelly
International Digital Dental Academy, Norwich NR14 8FB, UK
2 shared publications - Mark Ambridge
International Digital Dental Academy, Norwich NR14 8FB, UK
2 shared publications - Oliver Ambridge
International Digital Dental Academy, Norwich NR14 8FB, UK
2 shared publications
Latest Publications
- Open Access
- 9 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BDJ Open
- Vol. 12 (1) , 4
An in vitro study of the fixed edentulous implant guide using a novel approach to edentulous guided surgery using a developed two part screw
Introduction: Accurate implant placement in edentulous patients remains a clinical challenge, particularly when using mucosa-supported guides, which are prone to positional errors. Aims: To evaluate the accuracy of implant placement using the Fixed Edentulous Implant Guide (FEIG), a screw-retained guide system, compared with a conventional mucosa-supported guide in an edentulous mandible model. Materials and methods: Ten anatomical mandibular models with simulated mucosa and bone were used. Forty dummy implants were placed using either the FEIG system or a conventional guide. Implant positions were virtually planned, and deviations were assessed by comparing the planned and actual positions using STL-based alignment and a custom measurement algorithm. Results: The FEIG system demonstrated significantly lower mean deviations at the coronal (0.45 ± 0.15 mm) and apical (0.28 ± 0.13 mm) levels compared with the conventional guide (1.22 ± 0.61 mm and 0.89 ± 0.39 mm, respectively; p < 0.001). Angular deviation was lower for the FEIG (1.99° ± 0.98) but not statistically significant ( p = 0.081). Conclusions: The FEIG method significantly improved the accuracy of implant placement in vitro compared to a conventional edentulous guide. Further in vivo studies are warranted to confirm its clinical applicability.
- 9 January 2026
- Published by Springer Nature in BDJ Open
- Vol. 12 (1) , 4
Open AccessAn in vitro study of the fixed edentulous implant guide using a novel approach to edentulous guided surgery using a developed two part screw
Introduction: Accurate implant placement in edentulous patients remains a clinical challenge, particularly when using mucosa-supported guides, which are prone to positional errors. Aims: To evaluate the accuracy of implant placement using the Fixed Edentulous Implant Guide (FEIG), a screw-retained guide system, compared with a conventional mucosa-supported guide in an edentulous mandible model. Materials and methods: Ten anatomical mandibular models with simulated mucosa and bone were used. Forty dummy implants were placed using either the FEIG system or a conventional guide. Implant positions were virtually planned, and deviations were assessed by comparing the planned and actual positions using STL-based alignment and a custom measurement algorithm. Results: The FEIG system demonstrated significantly lower mean deviations at the coronal (0.45 ± 0.15 mm) and apical (0.28 ± 0.13 mm) levels compared with the conventional guide (1.22 ± 0.61 mm and 0.89 ± 0.39 mm, respectively; p < 0.001). Angular deviation was lower for the FEIG (1.99° ± 0.98) but not statistically significant ( p = 0.081). Conclusions: The FEIG method significantly improved the accuracy of implant placement in vitro compared to a conventional edentulous guide. Further in vivo studies are warranted to confirm its clinical applicability.
- Open Access
- 13 November 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Dentistry Journal
- Vol. 13 (11) , 533
In Vitro Comparison of Trueness and Precision of an AI-Driven Real-Time Library Matching Protocol with Irregular Geometry Scan Bodies for Full-Arch Implant Scanning
Background: Accurate digital transfer of implant positions is critical for the long-term success of full-arch prosthetic rehabilitation. Photogrammetry remains the benchmark for accuracy, but its high cost and complexity limit clinical adoption. Artificial intelligence (AI)-driven intraoral scanning protocols incorporating real-time library matching and irregular, individually coded scan bodies have been proposed as accessible alternatives to improve accuracy and reproducibility. Methods: This in vitro study evaluated the trueness and precision of a full-arch implant scanning workflow using an AI-assisted real-time library matching system in combination with irregular multi-geometry titanium scan bodies. A high-accuracy structured-light scanner served as the reference standard. Six implant positions (35, 33, 31, 41, 43, 45) were scanned across 20 datasets (n = 120). Mean surface deviations were calculated against the reference STL using CloudCompare v.2.14. and a two-way ANOVA (α = 0.05) in SPSS tested the effects of implant position and scan iteration. Results: The workflow achieved a mean deviation of 13.55 ± 9.70 μm (range 0.77–43.46 μm) across all positions. Anterior sites showed the lowest deviations (e.g., position 31: 3.95 μm; 45: 5.96 μm), while posterior sites exhibited higher deviations (e.g., position 43: 26.15 μm). No mean deviation exceeded 30 μm, and no individual measurement surpassed 45 μm. Implant position significantly affected accuracy (p < 0.001), whereas scan iteration did not (p > 0.05). Conclusions: Within the limitations of this in vitro model, an AI-assisted real-time library matching workflow used in conjunction with irregular multi-geometry scan bodies achieved accuracy levels well within clinically acceptable ranges for full-arch implant impressions. Although comparable to values reported for photogrammetry under laboratory conditions, clinical equivalence should not be assumed. Further in vivo validation is required to confirm performance under routine clinical conditions.
- 13 November 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Dentistry Journal
- Vol. 13 (11) , 533
Open AccessIn Vitro Comparison of Trueness and Precision of an AI-Driven Real-Time Library Matching Protocol with Irregular Geometry Scan Bodies for Full-Arch Implant Scanning
Background: Accurate digital transfer of implant positions is critical for the long-term success of full-arch prosthetic rehabilitation. Photogrammetry remains the benchmark for accuracy, but its high cost and complexity limit clinical adoption. Artificial intelligence (AI)-driven intraoral scanning protocols incorporating real-time library matching and irregular, individually coded scan bodies have been proposed as accessible alternatives to improve accuracy and reproducibility. Methods: This in vitro study evaluated the trueness and precision of a full-arch implant scanning workflow using an AI-assisted real-time library matching system in combination with irregular multi-geometry titanium scan bodies. A high-accuracy structured-light scanner served as the reference standard. Six implant positions (35, 33, 31, 41, 43, 45) were scanned across 20 datasets (n = 120). Mean surface deviations were calculated against the reference STL using CloudCompare v.2.14. and a two-way ANOVA (α = 0.05) in SPSS tested the effects of implant position and scan iteration. Results: The workflow achieved a mean deviation of 13.55 ± 9.70 μm (range 0.77–43.46 μm) across all positions. Anterior sites showed the lowest deviations (e.g., position 31: 3.95 μm; 45: 5.96 μm), while posterior sites exhibited higher deviations (e.g., position 43: 26.15 μm). No mean deviation exceeded 30 μm, and no individual measurement surpassed 45 μm. Implant position significantly affected accuracy (p < 0.001), whereas scan iteration did not (p > 0.05). Conclusions: Within the limitations of this in vitro model, an AI-assisted real-time library matching workflow used in conjunction with irregular multi-geometry scan bodies achieved accuracy levels well within clinically acceptable ranges for full-arch implant impressions. Although comparable to values reported for photogrammetry under laboratory conditions, clinical equivalence should not be assumed. Further in vivo validation is required to confirm performance under routine clinical conditions.
- Open Access
- 5 September 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
In Vitro Comparison of Trueness and Precision of Real Time Library Matching with Medit SmartX on Full Arch Implant Scanning Accuracy with Scan Ladder
Background: Accurate transfer of implant positions is essential for the long-term success of full-arch prosthetic rehabilitation. Photogrammetry is widely regarded as the gold standard for accuracy, but its high cost and complexity limit widespread use. Recent developments in artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted intraoral scanning, such as Medit’s SmartX protocol combined with the Scan Ladder system, may offer a simplified and cost-effective alternative. Methods: This in vitro study evaluated the trueness and precision of full-arch implant scans obtained with the Medit i900 intraoral scanner using SmartX real-time library matching and Scan Ladder scan bodies. A 3Shape E2 desktop scanner served as the reference standard. Six implant positions (35, 33, 31, 41, 43, 45) were scanned across 20 SmartX datasets (n = 120 observations). Average surface deviations were calculated against the master STL using CloudCompare software, and descriptive statistics and two-way ANOVA were performed in SPSS. Results: The SmartX + Scan Ladder workflow achieved a mean deviation of 11.41 μm with a standard deviation of 12.16 μm across all implant positions. Anterior sites (31: 4.7 μm; 45: 6.1 μm) showed the lowest deviations, while posterior sites exhibited slightly higher values (43: 22.5 μm). No mean deviation exceeded 25 μm, and no individual measurement surpassed 45 μm. Implant position was a significant factor influencing accuracy (P < .001), whereas scan iteration had no effect (P > .05). Conclusions: SmartX combined with Scan Ladder achieved trueness and precision within the sub-20 μm range, comparable to reported values for photogrammetry. These findings suggest that high-fidelity, full-arch digital implant impressions can be achieved using this simplified workflow. Further in vivo studies are required to validate clinical applicability under real-world conditions.
- 5 September 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Preprints.org
Open AccessIn Vitro Comparison of Trueness and Precision of Real Time Library Matching with Medit SmartX on Full Arch Implant Scanning Accuracy with Scan Ladder
Background: Accurate transfer of implant positions is essential for the long-term success of full-arch prosthetic rehabilitation. Photogrammetry is widely regarded as the gold standard for accuracy, but its high cost and complexity limit widespread use. Recent developments in artificial intelligence (AI)-assisted intraoral scanning, such as Medit’s SmartX protocol combined with the Scan Ladder system, may offer a simplified and cost-effective alternative. Methods: This in vitro study evaluated the trueness and precision of full-arch implant scans obtained with the Medit i900 intraoral scanner using SmartX real-time library matching and Scan Ladder scan bodies. A 3Shape E2 desktop scanner served as the reference standard. Six implant positions (35, 33, 31, 41, 43, 45) were scanned across 20 SmartX datasets (n = 120 observations). Average surface deviations were calculated against the master STL using CloudCompare software, and descriptive statistics and two-way ANOVA were performed in SPSS. Results: The SmartX + Scan Ladder workflow achieved a mean deviation of 11.41 μm with a standard deviation of 12.16 μm across all implant positions. Anterior sites (31: 4.7 μm; 45: 6.1 μm) showed the lowest deviations, while posterior sites exhibited slightly higher values (43: 22.5 μm). No mean deviation exceeded 25 μm, and no individual measurement surpassed 45 μm. Implant position was a significant factor influencing accuracy (P < .001), whereas scan iteration had no effect (P > .05). Conclusions: SmartX combined with Scan Ladder achieved trueness and precision within the sub-20 μm range, comparable to reported values for photogrammetry. These findings suggest that high-fidelity, full-arch digital implant impressions can be achieved using this simplified workflow. Further in vivo studies are required to validate clinical applicability under real-world conditions.
- Open Access
- 1 August 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Aesthetic Medicine
- Vol. 1 (1) , 4
AI-Driven Aesthetic Rehabilitation in Edentulous Arches: Advancing Symmetry and Smile Design Through Medit SmartX and Scan Ladder
The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) and advanced digital workflows is revolutionising full-arch implant dentistry, particularly for geriatric patients with edentulous and atrophic arches, for whom achieving both prosthetic passivity and optimal aesthetic outcomes is critical. This narrative review evaluates current challenges in intraoral scanning accuracy—such as scan distortion, angular deviation, and cross-arch misalignment—and presents how innovations like the Medit SmartX AI-guided workflow and the Scan Ladder system can significantly enhance precision in implant position registration. These technologies mitigate stitching errors by using real-time scan body recognition and auxiliary geometric references, yielding mean RMS trueness values as low as 11–13 µm, comparable to dedicated photogrammetry systems. AI-driven prosthetic design further aligns implant-supported restorations with facial symmetry and smile aesthetics, prioritising predictable midline and occlusal plane control. Early clinical data indicate that such tools can reduce prosthetic misfits to under 20 µm and lower complication rates related to passive fit, while shortening scan times by up to 30% compared to conventional workflows. This is especially valuable for elderly individuals who may not tolerate multiple lengthy adjustments. Additionally, emerging AI applications in design automation, scan validation, and patient-specific workflow adaptation continue to evolve, supporting more efficient and personalised digital prosthodontics. In summary, AI-enhanced scanning and prosthetic workflows do not merely meet functional demands but also elevate aesthetic standards in complex full-arch rehabilitations. The synergy of AI and digital dentistry presents a transformative opportunity to consistently deliver superior precision, passivity, and facial harmony for edentulous implant patients.
- 1 August 2025
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Aesthetic Medicine
- Vol. 1 (1) , 4
Open AccessAI-Driven Aesthetic Rehabilitation in Edentulous Arches: Advancing Symmetry and Smile Design Through Medit SmartX and Scan Ladder
The integration of artificial intelligence (AI) and advanced digital workflows is revolutionising full-arch implant dentistry, particularly for geriatric patients with edentulous and atrophic arches, for whom achieving both prosthetic passivity and optimal aesthetic outcomes is critical. This narrative review evaluates current challenges in intraoral scanning accuracy—such as scan distortion, angular deviation, and cross-arch misalignment—and presents how innovations like the Medit SmartX AI-guided workflow and the Scan Ladder system can significantly enhance precision in implant position registration. These technologies mitigate stitching errors by using real-time scan body recognition and auxiliary geometric references, yielding mean RMS trueness values as low as 11–13 µm, comparable to dedicated photogrammetry systems. AI-driven prosthetic design further aligns implant-supported restorations with facial symmetry and smile aesthetics, prioritising predictable midline and occlusal plane control. Early clinical data indicate that such tools can reduce prosthetic misfits to under 20 µm and lower complication rates related to passive fit, while shortening scan times by up to 30% compared to conventional workflows. This is especially valuable for elderly individuals who may not tolerate multiple lengthy adjustments. Additionally, emerging AI applications in design automation, scan validation, and patient-specific workflow adaptation continue to evolve, supporting more efficient and personalised digital prosthodontics. In summary, AI-enhanced scanning and prosthetic workflows do not merely meet functional demands but also elevate aesthetic standards in complex full-arch rehabilitations. The synergy of AI and digital dentistry presents a transformative opportunity to consistently deliver superior precision, passivity, and facial harmony for edentulous implant patients.
- Open Access
- 18 November 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Dentistry Journal
- Vol. 12 (11) , 367
An In Vivo Comparison of Trueness and Precision of Two Novel Methods for Improving Edentulous Full Arch Implant Scanning Accuracy: A Pilot Study
Background: This retrospective in vivo study evaluated the trueness and precision of two digital intraoral scanners—Dentsply Sirona Primescan and Medit i900—, both with and without two variants of the novel Scan Ladder aids, and compared their performance to a new intraoral photogrammetry scanner (Shining 3D Elite). Methods: Data from ten edentulous patients, previously collected during routine clinical treatment, were analyzed using a master STL generated from traditional impression casts as the reference. A custom positional change calculator and comprehensive statistical analysis were used to assess scanner accuracy. Results: The findings demonstrated that the use of the Scan Ladder significantly enhanced the overall accuracy of both intraoral scanners, showing no statistically significant differences when compared to the intraoral photogrammetry system. Conclusions: These results indicate that the Scan Ladder improves the performance of conventional intraoral scanners and suggests that the Shining 3D Elite intraoral photogrammetry scanner is a reliable alternative to extraoral photogrammetry for edentulous cases. Further research, with a larger and more diverse cohort, is warranted to validate and expand upon these findings.
- 18 November 2024
- Published by MDPI AG in Dentistry Journal
- Vol. 12 (11) , 367
Open AccessAn In Vivo Comparison of Trueness and Precision of Two Novel Methods for Improving Edentulous Full Arch Implant Scanning Accuracy: A Pilot Study
Background: This retrospective in vivo study evaluated the trueness and precision of two digital intraoral scanners—Dentsply Sirona Primescan and Medit i900—, both with and without two variants of the novel Scan Ladder aids, and compared their performance to a new intraoral photogrammetry scanner (Shining 3D Elite). Methods: Data from ten edentulous patients, previously collected during routine clinical treatment, were analyzed using a master STL generated from traditional impression casts as the reference. A custom positional change calculator and comprehensive statistical analysis were used to assess scanner accuracy. Results: The findings demonstrated that the use of the Scan Ladder significantly enhanced the overall accuracy of both intraoral scanners, showing no statistically significant differences when compared to the intraoral photogrammetry system. Conclusions: These results indicate that the Scan Ladder improves the performance of conventional intraoral scanners and suggests that the Shining 3D Elite intraoral photogrammetry scanner is a reliable alternative to extraoral photogrammetry for edentulous cases. Further research, with a larger and more diverse cohort, is warranted to validate and expand upon these findings.
- Open Access
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in British Dental Journal
- p. 1-6
A novel methodology for analysing dental implant positional changes from virtual planning to placement without CBCT
Introduction This paper introduces a novel methodology for analysing dental implant positioning in vivo, advancing beyond traditional methods that rely on post-placement cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) scans.Method The core of the methodology is comparing stereolithography (STL) files, representing pre-planned and actual post-placement implant positions. These STL files, exported from guided surgery planning and computer-aided design software, focus on clinically significant key points, like the apical and coronal midpoints. Additionally, the method uses pose detection, differing fundamentally from CBCT scan approximations.Discussion Relying on pose detection instead of scanner resolution, this method aligns with international standards and overcomes CBCT and intra-oral scanner limitations. It allows for a more precise and accurate assessment of implant positions, independent of scanner technology constraints. Further refinements include potential detailed reporting of apical deviations, enhancing implant placement accuracy.Conclusion This research has significant implications for dental implantology, enhancing implant placement precision and overall procedure success. Introducing an automated process for report generation through a batch script improves efficiency and precision, streamlining the analysis process. This innovation sets the stage for future technological advancements, improving both the accuracy and reliability of implant placement assessments.
- 4 October 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in British Dental Journal
- p. 1-6
Open AccessA novel methodology for analysing dental implant positional changes from virtual planning to placement without CBCT
Introduction This paper introduces a novel methodology for analysing dental implant positioning in vivo, advancing beyond traditional methods that rely on post-placement cone beam computed tomography (CBCT) scans.Method The core of the methodology is comparing stereolithography (STL) files, representing pre-planned and actual post-placement implant positions. These STL files, exported from guided surgery planning and computer-aided design software, focus on clinically significant key points, like the apical and coronal midpoints. Additionally, the method uses pose detection, differing fundamentally from CBCT scan approximations.Discussion Relying on pose detection instead of scanner resolution, this method aligns with international standards and overcomes CBCT and intra-oral scanner limitations. It allows for a more precise and accurate assessment of implant positions, independent of scanner technology constraints. Further refinements include potential detailed reporting of apical deviations, enhancing implant placement accuracy.Conclusion This research has significant implications for dental implantology, enhancing implant placement precision and overall procedure success. Introducing an automated process for report generation through a batch script improves efficiency and precision, streamlining the analysis process. This innovation sets the stage for future technological advancements, improving both the accuracy and reliability of implant placement assessments.
- Open Access
- 9 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in British Dental Journal
- Vol. 236 (3) , 169-180
A literature review on prosthetically designed guided implant placement and the factors influencing dental implant success
This is an extensive review of the literature on prosthetically designed implant planning with particular regard to the factors influencing dental implant success. Electronic searches on PubMed and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials and manual searches were performed. The author selected the studies according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria. Meta-analysis of implant placement accuracy and a qualitative review of potential influencing factors were performed.This literature review will explore prosthetically designed implant placement and its influence on dental implant success. By examining the factors that impact implant outcomes, this review aims to provide clinicians with a comprehensive understanding of the key considerations and best practices in achieving successful implant placements. Ultimately, this knowledge can contribute to enhancing patient care and the long-term success of dental implant treatments.
- 9 February 2024
- Published by Springer Nature in British Dental Journal
- Vol. 236 (3) , 169-180
Open AccessA literature review on prosthetically designed guided implant placement and the factors influencing dental implant success
This is an extensive review of the literature on prosthetically designed implant planning with particular regard to the factors influencing dental implant success. Electronic searches on PubMed and the Cochrane Central Register of Controlled Trials and manual searches were performed. The author selected the studies according to the inclusion and exclusion criteria. Meta-analysis of implant placement accuracy and a qualitative review of potential influencing factors were performed.This literature review will explore prosthetically designed implant placement and its influence on dental implant success. By examining the factors that impact implant outcomes, this review aims to provide clinicians with a comprehensive understanding of the key considerations and best practices in achieving successful implant placements. Ultimately, this knowledge can contribute to enhancing patient care and the long-term success of dental implant treatments.
- Open Access
- 8 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
An In Vivo Comparison of Trueness and Precision of a Novel Method to Improve Edentulous Intra-Oral Digital Scanner Accuracy with Full Arch Implant Scan Body Capture
Background The purpose of this in vivo study is to evaluate the full arch scan accuracy (precision and trueness) of two digital intra-oral scanners when using two variants of a novel method in an edentulous full arch implant case. Previous studies have compared the accuracy of intra-oral scanners, which have proven to be adequately accurate in dentate arches but are less accurate in edentulous arches which is critical in importance within the field of dental implant restorations where passivity is required; Methods The present in vivo study compared two different intraoral scanners (Primescan and i700 ) to investigate the accuracy of each scanner both with and without the novel method of using two variants of the Scan Ladder system by examining the overall trueness and precision compared to a verified lab scan of a traditional impression cast as the master STL. A comparison was made with the master STL using a direct implant position analysis using a positional change calculator. The results were recorded and the data compared using SPSS statistical software; Results In the present study, the overall trueness was significantly more accurate with each scanner using the novel method with either variant. Conclusions This study confirms that intra-oral digital scanners cannot capture a reliable, reproducible full arch implant scan in edentulous patients without a scanning aid such as the Scan Ladder. The study also confirms that the novel method provides increased levels of accuracy to each scanner used.
- 8 December 2023
- Published by Springer Nature in Research Square
Open AccessAn In Vivo Comparison of Trueness and Precision of a Novel Method to Improve Edentulous Intra-Oral Digital Scanner Accuracy with Full Arch Implant Scan Body Capture
Background The purpose of this in vivo study is to evaluate the full arch scan accuracy (precision and trueness) of two digital intra-oral scanners when using two variants of a novel method in an edentulous full arch implant case. Previous studies have compared the accuracy of intra-oral scanners, which have proven to be adequately accurate in dentate arches but are less accurate in edentulous arches which is critical in importance within the field of dental implant restorations where passivity is required; Methods The present in vivo study compared two different intraoral scanners (Primescan and i700 ) to investigate the accuracy of each scanner both with and without the novel method of using two variants of the Scan Ladder system by examining the overall trueness and precision compared to a verified lab scan of a traditional impression cast as the master STL. A comparison was made with the master STL using a direct implant position analysis using a positional change calculator. The results were recorded and the data compared using SPSS statistical software; Results In the present study, the overall trueness was significantly more accurate with each scanner using the novel method with either variant. Conclusions This study confirms that intra-oral digital scanners cannot capture a reliable, reproducible full arch implant scan in edentulous patients without a scanning aid such as the Scan Ladder. The study also confirms that the novel method provides increased levels of accuracy to each scanner used.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 26 May 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in BDJ Open
- Vol. 8 (1) , 1-9
A comparison of trueness and precision of 12 3D printers used in dentistry
Introduction: Judging the dimensional accuracy of the resulting printed part requires comparison and conformity between the 3D printed model and its virtual counterpart. The resolution and accuracy of 3D model samples are determined by a wide array of factors depending on the technology used and related factors such as the print head/laser spot size/screen resolution, build orientation, materials, geometric features, and their topology. Aims: The aim of this manuscript is to present a literature review on 12 3D printers, namely the Ackuretta Sol, Anycubic Photon and Photon S, Asiga Max UV, Elegoo Mars, Envisiontec Vida HD, Envisiontec One, Envisiontec D4K Pro, Formlabs Form 2 and Form 3, Nextdent 5100, and Planmeca Creo, studying the accuracy of these printers that are of a wide variety of budgets. Design: The present study involves some of the recently released 3D printers that have not yet been studied for their accuracy. Since these new printers will replace current models that may have been included in the previous studies in the literature, it is important to study whether they are statistically more or less accurate and to discuss whether these results are clinically relevant. For the purposes of this study, the use of a standardised printable object was used to measure the accuracy of these recent 3D printers. Materials and methods: In total, 12 3D printers produced test blocks. All test blocks were printed using the same settings with 100 micron Z layer thickness and the print time set to standard where applicable. To measure the resulting blocks a digital measurement was taken using a Dentsply Sirona Ineos X5 lab scanner to measure the XYZ dimensions of each block produced on each printer using CloudCompare to measure the deviation compared to the Master STL. Each measurement was taken from the central axis of that dimension. Results: When grouped into homogenous subsets, the cheapest 3D printers in the group, namely the Anycubic printers and the Elegoo Mars, are statistically not dissimilar to the higher priced Asiga Max UV or even the mid-priced Formlabs printers in the X and Z dimensions. However, the Envisiontec One and D4K Pro, Ackuretta Sol and Asiga Max UV were statistically superior in terms of consistently accurate Y dimension. Although these printers use different technologies to print, no specific type of printer technology is more accurate than the others. Discussion: The null hypothesis was proved to be true, in that no significant differences were found among the various technologies of 3D printing regarding trueness and precision. The evolution of 3D printers that leads to budget printers being as statistically accurate, for at least two of the dimensions of data recorded, as expensive printers is remarkable. Whilst clear differences in the mean error between the printers were found, the performance of these printers is considered exceptional. Albeit, the Envision One, Envision D4K, Ackuretta Sol and Asiga Max UV printers performed the best with overall trueness under 35 μm. Conclusion: This study shows that the current range of 3D printers can produce clinically acceptable levels of accuracy. The present study also shows that there is no statistical difference in the results of budget printers and more expensive printers for the X and Z dimensions but this was not the case for the measurements in the Y dimension. This study confirms that all of the 3D printers can produce a reliable, reproducible model.
- 26 May 2022
- Published by Springer Nature in BDJ Open
- Vol. 8 (1) , 1-9
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessA comparison of trueness and precision of 12 3D printers used in dentistry
Introduction: Judging the dimensional accuracy of the resulting printed part requires comparison and conformity between the 3D printed model and its virtual counterpart. The resolution and accuracy of 3D model samples are determined by a wide array of factors depending on the technology used and related factors such as the print head/laser spot size/screen resolution, build orientation, materials, geometric features, and their topology. Aims: The aim of this manuscript is to present a literature review on 12 3D printers, namely the Ackuretta Sol, Anycubic Photon and Photon S, Asiga Max UV, Elegoo Mars, Envisiontec Vida HD, Envisiontec One, Envisiontec D4K Pro, Formlabs Form 2 and Form 3, Nextdent 5100, and Planmeca Creo, studying the accuracy of these printers that are of a wide variety of budgets. Design: The present study involves some of the recently released 3D printers that have not yet been studied for their accuracy. Since these new printers will replace current models that may have been included in the previous studies in the literature, it is important to study whether they are statistically more or less accurate and to discuss whether these results are clinically relevant. For the purposes of this study, the use of a standardised printable object was used to measure the accuracy of these recent 3D printers. Materials and methods: In total, 12 3D printers produced test blocks. All test blocks were printed using the same settings with 100 micron Z layer thickness and the print time set to standard where applicable. To measure the resulting blocks a digital measurement was taken using a Dentsply Sirona Ineos X5 lab scanner to measure the XYZ dimensions of each block produced on each printer using CloudCompare to measure the deviation compared to the Master STL. Each measurement was taken from the central axis of that dimension. Results: When grouped into homogenous subsets, the cheapest 3D printers in the group, namely the Anycubic printers and the Elegoo Mars, are statistically not dissimilar to the higher priced Asiga Max UV or even the mid-priced Formlabs printers in the X and Z dimensions. However, the Envisiontec One and D4K Pro, Ackuretta Sol and Asiga Max UV were statistically superior in terms of consistently accurate Y dimension. Although these printers use different technologies to print, no specific type of printer technology is more accurate than the others. Discussion: The null hypothesis was proved to be true, in that no significant differences were found among the various technologies of 3D printing regarding trueness and precision. The evolution of 3D printers that leads to budget printers being as statistically accurate, for at least two of the dimensions of data recorded, as expensive printers is remarkable. Whilst clear differences in the mean error between the printers were found, the performance of these printers is considered exceptional. Albeit, the Envision One, Envision D4K, Ackuretta Sol and Asiga Max UV printers performed the best with overall trueness under 35 μm. Conclusion: This study shows that the current range of 3D printers can produce clinically acceptable levels of accuracy. The present study also shows that there is no statistical difference in the results of budget printers and more expensive printers for the X and Z dimensions but this was not the case for the measurements in the Y dimension. This study confirms that all of the 3D printers can produce a reliable, reproducible model.
- Top Cited PapersOpen Access
- 23 June 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Dentistry Journal
- Vol. 9 (7) , 75
A Comparison of Full Arch Trueness and Precision of Nine Intra-Oral Digital Scanners and Four Lab Digital Scanners
(1) Background: The purpose of this study is to evaluate the full arch scan accuracy (precision and trueness) of nine digital intra-oral scanners and four lab scanners. Previous studies have compared the accuracy of some intra-oral scanners, but as this is a field of quickly developing technologies, a more up-to-date study was needed to assess the capabilities of currently available models. (2) Methods: The present in vitro study compared nine different intra-oral scanners (Omnicam 4.6; Omnicam 5.1; Primescan; CS 3600; Trios 3; Trios 4; Runyes; i500; and DL206) as well as four lab light scanners (Einscan SE; 300e; E2; and Ineos X5) to investigate the accuracy of each scanner by examining the overall trueness and precision. Ten aligned and cut scans from each of the intra-oral and lab scanners in the in vitro study were brought into CloudCompare. A comparison was made with the master STL using the CloudCompare 3D analysis best-fit algorithm. The results were recorded along with individual standard deviation and a colorimetric map of the deviation across the surface of the STL mesh; a comparison was made to the master STL, quantified at specific points. (3) Results: In the present study, the Primescan had the best overall trueness (17.3 ± 4.9), followed by (in order of increasing deviation) the Trios 4 (20.8 ± 6.2), i500 (25.2 ± 7.3), CS3600 (26.9 ± 15.9), Trios 3 (27.7 ± 6.8), Runyes (47.2 ± 5.4), Omnicam 5.1 (55.1 ± 9.5), Omnicam 4.6 (57.5 ± 3.2), and Launca DL206 (58.5 ± 22.0). Regarding the lab light scanners, the Ineos X5 had the best overall trueness with (0.0 ± 1.9), followed by (in order of increasing deviation) the 3Shape E2 (3.6 ± 2.2), Up3D 300E (12.8 ± 2.7), and Einscan SE (14.9 ± 9.5). (4) Conclusions: This study confirms that all current generations of intra-oral digital scanners can capture a reliable, reproducible full arch scan in dentate patients. Out of the intra-oral scanners tested, no scanner produced results significantly similar in trueness to the Ineos X5. However, the Primescan was the only one to be statistically of a similar level of trueness to the 3Shape E2 lab scanner. All scanners in the study had mean trueness of under 60-micron deviation. While this study can compare the scanning accuracy of this sample in a dentate arch, the scanning of a fully edentulous arch is more challenging. The accuracy of these scanners in edentulous cases should be examined in further studies.
- 23 June 2021
- Published by MDPI AG in Dentistry Journal
- Vol. 9 (7) , 75
Top Cited PapersOpen AccessA Comparison of Full Arch Trueness and Precision of Nine Intra-Oral Digital Scanners and Four Lab Digital Scanners
(1) Background: The purpose of this study is to evaluate the full arch scan accuracy (precision and trueness) of nine digital intra-oral scanners and four lab scanners. Previous studies have compared the accuracy of some intra-oral scanners, but as this is a field of quickly developing technologies, a more up-to-date study was needed to assess the capabilities of currently available models. (2) Methods: The present in vitro study compared nine different intra-oral scanners (Omnicam 4.6; Omnicam 5.1; Primescan; CS 3600; Trios 3; Trios 4; Runyes; i500; and DL206) as well as four lab light scanners (Einscan SE; 300e; E2; and Ineos X5) to investigate the accuracy of each scanner by examining the overall trueness and precision. Ten aligned and cut scans from each of the intra-oral and lab scanners in the in vitro study were brought into CloudCompare. A comparison was made with the master STL using the CloudCompare 3D analysis best-fit algorithm. The results were recorded along with individual standard deviation and a colorimetric map of the deviation across the surface of the STL mesh; a comparison was made to the master STL, quantified at specific points. (3) Results: In the present study, the Primescan had the best overall trueness (17.3 ± 4.9), followed by (in order of increasing deviation) the Trios 4 (20.8 ± 6.2), i500 (25.2 ± 7.3), CS3600 (26.9 ± 15.9), Trios 3 (27.7 ± 6.8), Runyes (47.2 ± 5.4), Omnicam 5.1 (55.1 ± 9.5), Omnicam 4.6 (57.5 ± 3.2), and Launca DL206 (58.5 ± 22.0). Regarding the lab light scanners, the Ineos X5 had the best overall trueness with (0.0 ± 1.9), followed by (in order of increasing deviation) the 3Shape E2 (3.6 ± 2.2), Up3D 300E (12.8 ± 2.7), and Einscan SE (14.9 ± 9.5). (4) Conclusions: This study confirms that all current generations of intra-oral digital scanners can capture a reliable, reproducible full arch scan in dentate patients. Out of the intra-oral scanners tested, no scanner produced results significantly similar in trueness to the Ineos X5. However, the Primescan was the only one to be statistically of a similar level of trueness to the 3Shape E2 lab scanner. All scanners in the study had mean trueness of under 60-micron deviation. While this study can compare the scanning accuracy of this sample in a dentate arch, the scanning of a fully edentulous arch is more challenging. The accuracy of these scanners in edentulous cases should be examined in further studies.