KIKarina A. Ionkina

Karina A. Ionkina

*This is an algorithmically generated author record based on publicly available information.

Current Organizations / Institutes

The organizations/institutes from the scholar's latest article


Karina A. Ionkina has a total of 8 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:


Latest Publications

  • Open Access

    Structural Alternatives for Price Stabilization in Commodity Markets

    by Александр Александрович Курдин, Карина Александровна Ионкина

    The article is devoted to the development of approaches to state regulation of commodity markets in order to stabilize prices during periods of price shocks. The authors systematize the measures of state regulation used in Russian and world practice to overcome price shocks, including foreign trade restrictions, fiscal measures, commodity and purchasing interventions. Particular attention is paid to the policy of development of the exchange segment of commodity markets as a potentially pro-competitive tool for improving market mechanisms, the emphasis on which is made by the FAS of Russia as part of achieving medium-term objectives of competition policy, trying to form a system of national price indicators. Following the ideology of regulatory impact assessment, the authors identify six key criteria for comparing alternatives of market regulation, including price stability, reliability of supply, minimization of costs for the state budget and transaction costs for market participants, support for domestic industries, and technological capabilities. According to these criteria, the authors compare ten main alternatives. They come to the conclusion that the establishment of a system of price indicators that allow for the prompt and reasonable application of antitrust response measures shows a good balance of benefits and costs, but these indicators should not be universally reduced to exchange quotations. Exchange pricing alone does not necessarily ensure price stability, can create additional costs for market participants by disrupting long-term supply chains, and is not always justified by the characteristics of commodities. Alternative mechanisms – damper, interventions, export bans – may be better in terms of rapid stabilization, but they bring negative effects in terms of incentives for producers and/or burdens on the state budget.

  • Open Access

    Is Antitrust Still Antitrust? Trends in Competition Policy and Antitrust Enforcement

    by K. A. Ionkina, A. N. Morozov

    This article identifies major trends in the development of competition and antitrust policy over the past ten years and relates them to standard antitrust objectives. The study concentrates on competition policy with emphasis on how antitrust measures operate as one component in it. The hypothesis that there is regulatory bias in contemporary antitrust policy is explored and assessed in terms of a broader debate about the prevalence of a fundamentalist approach in economic policy. Several case studies are adduced to illustrate the following trends: increased focus by antimonopoly authorities on digital markets, pro-competitive regulation of those markets, and antitrust investigations into digital platforms. The article continues with a discussion of the proliferation of populist measures associated with antitrust objectives. The growing use of competition policy for solving social problems and for purposes beyond those of traditional competition policy (such as governing technology transfer and addressing protectionism) is examined. Each of the trends described are shown to exhibit inconsistencies between the measures taken and the policy objective of enhancing competition with the result that regulation of digital markets intensifies (and becomes direct regulation in some instances), relies on normative rather than objective analysis, and leads to implementation of industrial policy through antitrust measures. The progression toward direct regulation bolsters the hypothesis that regulatory fundamentalism has become quite prevalent as part of competition policy in recent years.


  • New adventures of oligopolist companies in Russia: On the compatibility of economic theory and law in antitrust

    by A. E. Shastitko, K. A. Ionkina

    We offer an economic explanation of the position of the Presidium of the Russian Supreme Court regarding the application of the norm on collective dominance which was formulated in the “Review of judicial practice related to bringing to administrative responsibility for violations of antimonopoly legislation”. Our results are based on a literature review and a brief retrospective analysis of antimonopoly cases concerning collectively dominant companies. This paper provides arguments for the conclusion on the restoration of the principle of complementarity, compatibility of economic theory and law, the theory of oligopoly and the concept of collective dominance. The significance of the approach proposed by the Supreme Court of the Russian Federation to the application of the norm on collective dominance is explained using the concept of meso-institutions. We have uncovered potential challenges and opportunities for various interest groups in the light of expected significant institutional changes which are not related with changes in the relevant norms of the Russian legislation.

  • Institutional response after technological changes in telecommunications

    by A. E. Shastitko, К. A. Ionkina

    Imbalances in law enforcement require some alternatives for an institutional response to challenges. Telecommunications is an example industry where technological changes in the environment condition the need to adjust approaches for implementing antitrust tools for competition protection. The article deals with the discussion regarding the choice of structural alternatives for the framework of telecommunications (the institutional framework of this industry). The paper reveals the characteristics of competing alternatives: deregulation (regulation “pending”), economic regulation, reconfiguration of antitrust taking into account the limitations on the side of the regulator. It is shown that the solutions proposed on the basis of the Austrian school of economics and Pigouvian ideas are easily accessible in the framework of public discussions. This is why the economic regulation or deregulation are the most promising directions in the field of public policy. The Coasian approach requires better knowledge of the subject and allows to take into account the limitations on the side of the regulator, however, it is not likely to be accepted. At the same time, this approach provides a wider range of tools as a condition for the adaptive effectiveness of regulation.


  • Open Access

    Estimating the effects of legalizing drug e-commerce

    by Stanislav V. Spektor, Karina A. Ionkina

    With the technological development the e-commerce channel began to spread to all sectors of the economy. In 2020 with the introduction of sanitary and epidemiological restrictions because of COVID-19 pandemic, many countries lifted the ban of drug e-commerce. Such changes are interesting from the point of view of health economics, and the opening of this sales channel significantly reduces transaction costs and increases the physical availability of drugs, especially in regions with low population density. The article attempts to evaluate the effects of legalization of online sales of drugs on price level and the degree of market concentration (the concentration of the 5 largest companies is used as a proxy), and also uses new methods to estimate the effects of legalizing e-commerce on drug markets. High rates of industry and drug market concentration can lead to a noticeable decrease in the availability of goods. Legalizing e-commerce can be seen as a way to reduce market concentration by facilitating market entry for small firms. The effects of lifting the ban on remote drug sales are estimated using regression analysis on panel data, cross-country matching, and synthetic control. Empirical estimates provide an overall picture of the effects of legalizing online drug sales. After allowing remote drug sales market concentration decreases, indicating a reduction in information asymmetry and switching costs. This effect is particularly important for countries with a high proportion of pensioners, for whom the switching costs are noticeably higher ceteris paribus. Allowing distance trade, due to reducing information asymmetry, drug pricing also slows down, that is, in addition to increasing physical accessibility, opening this channel also increases economic accessibility.

  • Individual Abuse of Collective Dominance in Cellular Communications: Problems of Identification

    by Lomonosov Moscow State University, Andrey E. Shastitko, Iaer Ranepa, Karina A. Ionkina, Lomonosov Moscow State University; IAER RANEPA, Natalia S. Pavlova

    Recently, discussions about the validity of the Russian practice of establishing the facts of individual abuse of collective dominance have been escalating: many experts point to a contradiction between the meaning of collective dominance, in which a small number of companies have a joint dominant position, in connection with each other, and the possibility of an individual company to abuse this position. The purpose of the article is to assess the correctness of this approach in the context of recent antitrust cases in the cellular communications market – in particular, two cases against the mobile operator “Tele2”. In the article, the applied practice is assessed in relation to the currently known results in the field of economic theory, as well as international best practices in the application of the concept of collective dominance. The findings indicate that the conclusion of the FAS Russia on the presence of the dominant position of Tele2 as part of collective dominance and the possibility of the company to exercise its market power does not correspond to either foreign practice or industrial organization theory. The source of error in the qualification of behavior is largely due to the focus of the antimonopoly authority on quantitative criteria of collective dominance to the detriment of the analysis of qualitative criteria and behavior. This case illustrates a typical tendency for such cases not to investigate the behavior of other collectively dominant market participants in relation to the behavior of the company accused of individual abuse, as well as not to investigate consumer behavior, and, in particular, their real possibilities to switch and switching actions. The article was written on the basis of the RANEPA state assignment research programme.


  • Chimera of domestic antitrust: Institute of collective dominance in Russia

    by A. E. Shastitko, K. A. Ionkina

    The paper defines the features of the collective dominance institute in Russia as well as the relation between collective dominance and oligopoly in the spheres of law and economic theory. The article evaluates the grounds and consequences of the collective dominance legal norm application; it suggests an approach to examining the relation between effects and expected results of this legal norm application and outlines the potential ways to harmonize the best international practices of the collective dominance norm application with the existing economic standards of product market analysis for the purpose of competition law enforcement. Results of the oligopoly theory and the Russian version of collective dominance institution key elements comparison show: the collective dominance institution concept is inadequately applied to identify individual abuse of dominant position due to possible law enforcement errors. The Russian version of collective dominance institution reflects one fundamental tendency intrinsic to Russian antitrust: examined more closely, law enforcement, which is de jure aimed at protecting competition, appears to be economic regulation, which de facto can lead to competition restriction. One of the possible structural alternatives for the collective dominance institution reforming is based on presumption of the need to analyze the joint impact exerted by a group of undertakings on the market.