Ravi K. Bonam
Ravi K. Bonam has a total of 29 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Luciana Meli
IBM Semiconductor Research, Albany, New York
2 shared publicationsAlain C. Diebold
College of Nanoscale Science and Engineering, State University of New YorkAlbany, New York 12203
1 shared publication- Anuja De Silva
Lam Research Belgium BV, Leuven, Belgium
1 shared publication - Assad A. Oberai
Department of Aerospace and Mechanical Engineering, University of Southern California, Los Angeles, CA 90089, USA
1 shared publication Brad Austin
IBM Semiconductor Research, Albany, New York
1 shared publicationBrennan Peterson
Nanometrics Inc., 1550 Buckeye Dr., Milpitas, California 95035
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 July 2020
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
- Vol. 19 (03) , 034001-10
Fundamental characterization of stochastic variation for improved single-expose extreme ultraviolet patterning at aggressive pitch
Background: With aggressive scaling of single-expose (SE) extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography to the sub-7-nm node, stochastic variations play a prominent role in defining the lithographic process window (PW). Fluctuations in photon shot noise, absorption, and subsequent chemical reactions can lead to stochastic failure, directly impacting electrical yield. Aim: Fundamental characterization of the mode and magnitude of these variations is required to define the threshold for failure. Approach: A complementary series of techniques is enlisted to probe the nature and modulation of stochastic variation in SE EUV patterning. Unbiased line edge roughness (LER), local critical dimension uniformity (LCDU), and defect inspection techniques are employed to monitor the frequency of stochastic variations leading to failures in line/space (L/S) and via patterning. Results: When characterizing different resists and illumination conditions, there is no change in unbiased LER or via LCDU with increasing critical dimension (CD). Stochastic defect density is correlated with CD for both L/S and via arrays, and there is a strong correlation with L/S electrical yield data. Conclusions: Traditional 3σ LER and via LCDU measurements are not sensitive enough to define and improve PW. For PW centering and yield improvement, stochastic defect inspection is a necessity.
- 1 July 2020
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
- Vol. 19 (03) , 034001-10
Fundamental characterization of stochastic variation for improved single-expose extreme ultraviolet patterning at aggressive pitch
Background: With aggressive scaling of single-expose (SE) extreme ultraviolet (EUV) lithography to the sub-7-nm node, stochastic variations play a prominent role in defining the lithographic process window (PW). Fluctuations in photon shot noise, absorption, and subsequent chemical reactions can lead to stochastic failure, directly impacting electrical yield. Aim: Fundamental characterization of the mode and magnitude of these variations is required to define the threshold for failure. Approach: A complementary series of techniques is enlisted to probe the nature and modulation of stochastic variation in SE EUV patterning. Unbiased line edge roughness (LER), local critical dimension uniformity (LCDU), and defect inspection techniques are employed to monitor the frequency of stochastic variations leading to failures in line/space (L/S) and via patterning. Results: When characterizing different resists and illumination conditions, there is no change in unbiased LER or via LCDU with increasing critical dimension (CD). Stochastic defect density is correlated with CD for both L/S and via arrays, and there is a strong correlation with L/S electrical yield data. Conclusions: Traditional 3σ LER and via LCDU measurements are not sensitive enough to define and improve PW. For PW centering and yield improvement, stochastic defect inspection is a necessity.
- 1 April 2020
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
- Vol. 19 (02) , 024801-15
Deep learning-based detection, classification, and localization of defects in semiconductor processes
Defects in semiconductor processes can limit yield, increase overall production cost, and also lead to time-dependent critical component failures. Current state-of-the-art optical and electron beam (EB) inspection systems rely on rule-based techniques for defect detection and classification, which are usually rigid in their comparative processes. This rigidity limits overall capability and increases relative engineering time to classify nuisance defects. This is further challenged due to shrinkage of pattern dimensions for advanced nodes. We propose a deep learning-based workflow that circumvents these challenges and enables accurate defect detection, classification, and localization in a unified framework. In particular, we train convolutional neural network-based models using high-resolution EB images of wafers patterned with various types of intentional defects and achieve robust defect detection and classification performance. Furthermore, we generate class activation maps to demonstrate defect localization capability of the model “without” explicitly training it with defect location information. To understand the underlying decision-making process of these deep models, we analyze the learned filters in pixel space and Fourier space and interpret the various operations at different layers. We achieve high sensitivity (97%) and specificity (100%) along with rapid and accurate defect localization. We also test performance of the proposed workflow on images from two distinct patterns and find that in order to retain high accuracy a modest level of retraining is necessary.
- 1 April 2020
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
- Vol. 19 (02) , 024801-15
Deep learning-based detection, classification, and localization of defects in semiconductor processes
Defects in semiconductor processes can limit yield, increase overall production cost, and also lead to time-dependent critical component failures. Current state-of-the-art optical and electron beam (EB) inspection systems rely on rule-based techniques for defect detection and classification, which are usually rigid in their comparative processes. This rigidity limits overall capability and increases relative engineering time to classify nuisance defects. This is further challenged due to shrinkage of pattern dimensions for advanced nodes. We propose a deep learning-based workflow that circumvents these challenges and enables accurate defect detection, classification, and localization in a unified framework. In particular, we train convolutional neural network-based models using high-resolution EB images of wafers patterned with various types of intentional defects and achieve robust defect detection and classification performance. Furthermore, we generate class activation maps to demonstrate defect localization capability of the model “without” explicitly training it with defect location information. To understand the underlying decision-making process of these deep models, we analyze the learned filters in pixel space and Fourier space and interpret the various operations at different layers. We achieve high sensitivity (97%) and specificity (100%) along with rapid and accurate defect localization. We also test performance of the proposed workflow on images from two distinct patterns and find that in order to retain high accuracy a modest level of retraining is necessary.
- 4 October 2017
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Semiconductor Manufacturing
- Vol. 30 (4) , 402-409
Detection of Printable EUV Mask Absorber Defects and Defect Adders by Full Chip Optical Inspection of EUV Patterned Wafers
The ability to rapidly detect both printable EUV mask adder defects as well as mask absorber defects across the entire mask image field is a key enabler for EUV lithography. Current optical wafer-based inspection techniques are only capable of detecting repeater defects on a Die-to-Die basis for chiplets within the image field. Larger server-type chips that encompass the entire mask image field cannot rely on such a scheme, since the presence of the defect in every die prevents their detection. In this study, a prototype optical wafer defect inspection methodology designed to detect repeater defects over the entire image field, termed Die-to-Baseline Reference Die (D2BRD), is investigated. The sensitivity of this inspection technique is demonstrated and compared to eBeam inspection over a range of defect sizes for both opaque and clear type mask absorber programmed defects. Moreover, the D2BRD methodology is used to monitor printing defect adders present in a lithographic defect test mask, as well as 7 nm BEOL layers. Using defect repeater analysis, SEM review and patch image classification of full chip wafer inspections over several mask cycles, the D2BRD scheme is shown to allow the unambiguous identification of mask adder defects, while suppressing random process defects. This methodology has the potential to define the risk assessment of mask adder defects in the absence of an EUV pellicle, and can play an integral part of the wafer print protection strategy.
- 4 October 2017
- Published by Institute of Electrical and Electronics Engineers (IEEE) in IEEE Transactions on Semiconductor Manufacturing
- Vol. 30 (4) , 402-409
Detection of Printable EUV Mask Absorber Defects and Defect Adders by Full Chip Optical Inspection of EUV Patterned Wafers
The ability to rapidly detect both printable EUV mask adder defects as well as mask absorber defects across the entire mask image field is a key enabler for EUV lithography. Current optical wafer-based inspection techniques are only capable of detecting repeater defects on a Die-to-Die basis for chiplets within the image field. Larger server-type chips that encompass the entire mask image field cannot rely on such a scheme, since the presence of the defect in every die prevents their detection. In this study, a prototype optical wafer defect inspection methodology designed to detect repeater defects over the entire image field, termed Die-to-Baseline Reference Die (D2BRD), is investigated. The sensitivity of this inspection technique is demonstrated and compared to eBeam inspection over a range of defect sizes for both opaque and clear type mask absorber programmed defects. Moreover, the D2BRD methodology is used to monitor printing defect adders present in a lithographic defect test mask, as well as 7 nm BEOL layers. Using defect repeater analysis, SEM review and patch image classification of full chip wafer inspections over several mask cycles, the D2BRD scheme is shown to allow the unambiguous identification of mask adder defects, while suppressing random process defects. This methodology has the potential to define the risk assessment of mask adder defects in the absence of an EUV pellicle, and can play an integral part of the wafer print protection strategy.
- 1 February 2016
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
- Vol. 15 (2) , 021004
Printability of buried extreme ultraviolet lithography photomask defects
Native acting phase-programmed defects, otherwise known as buried program defects, with attributes very similar to native defects, were successfully fabricated using a high-accuracy overlay technique. The defect detectability and visibility were analyzed with conventional amplitude and phase-contrast blank inspection at 193-nm wavelength, pattern inspection at 193-nm wavelength, and scanning electron microscopy. The mask was also printed on wafer, and printability is discussed. Finally, the inspection sensitivity and wafer printability are compared, leading to the observation that the current blank- and pattern-inspection sensitivity is not enough to detect all of the printable defects.
- 1 February 2016
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
- Vol. 15 (2) , 021004
Printability of buried extreme ultraviolet lithography photomask defects
Native acting phase-programmed defects, otherwise known as buried program defects, with attributes very similar to native defects, were successfully fabricated using a high-accuracy overlay technique. The defect detectability and visibility were analyzed with conventional amplitude and phase-contrast blank inspection at 193-nm wavelength, pattern inspection at 193-nm wavelength, and scanning electron microscopy. The mask was also printed on wafer, and printability is discussed. Finally, the inspection sensitivity and wafer printability are compared, leading to the observation that the current blank- and pattern-inspection sensitivity is not enough to detect all of the printable defects.
- 1 January 2013
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
- Vol. 12 (1) , 013018
Characterization of e-beam patterned grating structures using Mueller matrix based scatterometry
Scatterometry is one of the most useful metrology methods for the characterization and control of critical dimensions and the detailed feature shape of periodic structures found in the microelectronics fabrication processes. Spectroscopic ellipsometry (SE) and normal incidence reflectometry (NI)-based scatterometry are widely used optical methodologies for metrology of these structures. Evolution of improved optical hardware and faster computing capabilities led to the development of Mueller matrix (MM)-based scatterometry (MMS). Unlike SE and NI, MM data provides complete information about the optical reflection and transmission of polarized light interacting with a sample. This gives MMS an advantage over traditional SE scatterometry due to the ability to characterize samples that have anisotropic optical properties and depolarize light. In this paper, we present the study of full MM (16-element) scatterometry over a wide spectral range from 245 to 1700 nm on a series of one-dimensional, two-dimensional symmetric, and asymmetric grating structures. A series of laterally complex nanoscale structures were designed and fabricated using a state-of-the-art e-beam patterning. Spectroscopic MM and SE data were collected using a dual rotating compensator ellipsometer. Commercial modeling software based on the rigorous coupled-wave approximation was used to precisely calculate the critical dimensions. Results from MMS were compared with scanning electron microscopy.
- 1 January 2013
- Published by SPIE-Intl Soc Optical Eng in Journal of Micro/Nanolithography, MEMS, and MOEMS
- Vol. 12 (1) , 013018
Characterization of e-beam patterned grating structures using Mueller matrix based scatterometry
Scatterometry is one of the most useful metrology methods for the characterization and control of critical dimensions and the detailed feature shape of periodic structures found in the microelectronics fabrication processes. Spectroscopic ellipsometry (SE) and normal incidence reflectometry (NI)-based scatterometry are widely used optical methodologies for metrology of these structures. Evolution of improved optical hardware and faster computing capabilities led to the development of Mueller matrix (MM)-based scatterometry (MMS). Unlike SE and NI, MM data provides complete information about the optical reflection and transmission of polarized light interacting with a sample. This gives MMS an advantage over traditional SE scatterometry due to the ability to characterize samples that have anisotropic optical properties and depolarize light. In this paper, we present the study of full MM (16-element) scatterometry over a wide spectral range from 245 to 1700 nm on a series of one-dimensional, two-dimensional symmetric, and asymmetric grating structures. A series of laterally complex nanoscale structures were designed and fabricated using a state-of-the-art e-beam patterning. Spectroscopic MM and SE data were collected using a dual rotating compensator ellipsometer. Commercial modeling software based on the rigorous coupled-wave approximation was used to precisely calculate the critical dimensions. Results from MMS were compared with scanning electron microscopy.