Stanislaw Szpala
Research Subjects
Stanislaw Szpala has a total of 12 co-authors. Here are the top co-authors by number of shared publications:
Kirpal Kohli
BC Cancer Surrey Centre Surrey BC Canada
3 shared publicationsAlastair Kyle
BC Cancer Research Centre Vancouver BC Canada
1 shared publication- Alexandra Bourgouin
National Research Council of Canada, Metrology Research Centre, 1200 Montreal Road, Ottawa, K1A0R6, ON, Canada
1 shared publication Andrew Minchinton
BC Cancer Research Centre Vancouver BC Canada
1 shared publication- Bryan R. Muir
National Research Council Canada
1 shared publication Fred Cao
Department of Physics BC Cancer Agency Surrey BC Canada
1 shared publication
Latest Publications
- 1 June 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Biomedical Physics & Engineering Express
- Vol. 12 (3) , 035093
Dosimetric impact of hysteresis in gantry rotation on clinical VMAT plans
Gantry angle inaccuracies during treatment delivery affect the dose distribution received by the patient. These inaccuracies may arise from stretching of the gantry belt, leading to hysteresis in the gantry angle. The purpose of this work is to determine the impact of gantry hysteresis on the dose distribution of representative volumetric modulated arc therapy plans and to evaluate whether current quality assurance guidelines for gantry angle tolerances are adequate in these cases. Simulations were performed in Eclipse by encoding gantry errors with various amounts of hysteresis. The impact on the dose constraints and the gamma index passing rates computed relative to the as-planned dose distribution was examined in five clinical plans: brain stereotactic radiosurgery, prostate with nodes, lung stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) and spine SBRT. The hysteresis thresholds, defined as the amount of gantry angle error causing a 1.0% dose-constraint change or a gamma reduction to 90%, were identified for gross tumor volumes, planning target volumes (PTVs) and selected organs at risks (OARs). D99%, D98% and gamma (1.0%, 0.01 mm) in the targets decreased with increasing hysteresis. The hysteresis threshold for the D98% or D99% ratios to the planned values ranged from 1.0° to 11.0°, with the smallest value (indicating the highest sensitivity) observed in the multi-met brain plan. Thresholds for the gamma analysis ranged from 0.5° to 7.7°, with the smallest value in the double-met lung SBRT plan. All dose metrics in the OARs decreased with increasing hysteresis, except for the D25% ratio in the bladder of the prostate/pelvis plan. The corresponding gamma passing rates decreased as hysteresis increased. Maintaining gantry hysteresis within 1.0° allowed dose-volume histogram -based metrics to remain within 1.0% of the planned values for all targets and OARs. The corresponding gamma passing rates remained above 90% for all OARs and for all but two PTVs. Limiting hysteresis to 0.5° ensured that all metrics stayed within tolerance.
- 1 June 2026
- Published by IOP Publishing in Biomedical Physics & Engineering Express
- Vol. 12 (3) , 035093
Dosimetric impact of hysteresis in gantry rotation on clinical VMAT plans
Gantry angle inaccuracies during treatment delivery affect the dose distribution received by the patient. These inaccuracies may arise from stretching of the gantry belt, leading to hysteresis in the gantry angle. The purpose of this work is to determine the impact of gantry hysteresis on the dose distribution of representative volumetric modulated arc therapy plans and to evaluate whether current quality assurance guidelines for gantry angle tolerances are adequate in these cases. Simulations were performed in Eclipse by encoding gantry errors with various amounts of hysteresis. The impact on the dose constraints and the gamma index passing rates computed relative to the as-planned dose distribution was examined in five clinical plans: brain stereotactic radiosurgery, prostate with nodes, lung stereotactic body radiation therapy (SBRT) and spine SBRT. The hysteresis thresholds, defined as the amount of gantry angle error causing a 1.0% dose-constraint change or a gamma reduction to 90%, were identified for gross tumor volumes, planning target volumes (PTVs) and selected organs at risks (OARs). D99%, D98% and gamma (1.0%, 0.01 mm) in the targets decreased with increasing hysteresis. The hysteresis threshold for the D98% or D99% ratios to the planned values ranged from 1.0° to 11.0°, with the smallest value (indicating the highest sensitivity) observed in the multi-met brain plan. Thresholds for the gamma analysis ranged from 0.5° to 7.7°, with the smallest value in the double-met lung SBRT plan. All dose metrics in the OARs decreased with increasing hysteresis, except for the D25% ratio in the bladder of the prostate/pelvis plan. The corresponding gamma passing rates decreased as hysteresis increased. Maintaining gantry hysteresis within 1.0° allowed dose-volume histogram -based metrics to remain within 1.0% of the planned values for all targets and OARs. The corresponding gamma passing rates remained above 90% for all OARs and for all but two PTVs. Limiting hysteresis to 0.5° ensured that all metrics stayed within tolerance.
- 29 December 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 68 (1) , 015019
Calorimeter measurements of absolute dose in aluminum, a surrogate of bone, to validate dose-to-medium in Acuros XB
Objective . While the accuracy of dose calculations in water with Acuros XB is well established, experimental validation of dose in bone is limited. Acuros XB reports both dose-to-medium and dose-to-water, and these values differ in bone, but there are no reports of measurements of validation in bone. This work compares Acuros XB calculations to measurements of absolute dose in aluminum (medium similar to bone). The validity of using selected relative dosimeters in aluminum is also investigated. Approach . A calorimeter with an aluminum core embedded in an aluminum phantom was selected as bone surrogate for the measurement of absolute dose. Matching the medium of the core to the medium of the phantom allowed eliminating the calculation of the conversion between media. The dose was measured at the fixed depth of 3.3 cm in aluminum (∼9 g·cm −2 ) with 6X, 10X, 6FFF and 10FFF photon beams from a TrueBeam Varian linac. In addition, experimental cross-calibration between water and aluminum was performed for an IBA CC13 ionization chamber, a PTW microDiamond and EBT3 Gafchromic film. Main results . Calculations with Acuros XB dose-to-medium in aluminum differed from the calorimetry data by −2.8% to −3.5%, depending on the beam. Use of dose-to-water would have resulted in about 39% discrepancy. The cross calibration coefficient between water and aluminum yielded values of about 0.87 for the CC13 chamber, 0.91 for the microDiamond, and 0.88 for the film, and independent of the beam within about ±1%. Significance . It was demonstrated the value of the dose-to-medium in aluminum (surrogate of bone) computed with Acuros XB is close to the value of the absolute dose measured with a calorimeter, and there is a significant discrepancy when dose-to-water is used instead. The use of an ionization chamber, a microDiamond and Gafchromic film in aluminum required a considerable correction from calibration in water.
- 29 December 2022
- Published by IOP Publishing in Physics in Medicine & Biology
- Vol. 68 (1) , 015019
Calorimeter measurements of absolute dose in aluminum, a surrogate of bone, to validate dose-to-medium in Acuros XB
Objective . While the accuracy of dose calculations in water with Acuros XB is well established, experimental validation of dose in bone is limited. Acuros XB reports both dose-to-medium and dose-to-water, and these values differ in bone, but there are no reports of measurements of validation in bone. This work compares Acuros XB calculations to measurements of absolute dose in aluminum (medium similar to bone). The validity of using selected relative dosimeters in aluminum is also investigated. Approach . A calorimeter with an aluminum core embedded in an aluminum phantom was selected as bone surrogate for the measurement of absolute dose. Matching the medium of the core to the medium of the phantom allowed eliminating the calculation of the conversion between media. The dose was measured at the fixed depth of 3.3 cm in aluminum (∼9 g·cm −2 ) with 6X, 10X, 6FFF and 10FFF photon beams from a TrueBeam Varian linac. In addition, experimental cross-calibration between water and aluminum was performed for an IBA CC13 ionization chamber, a PTW microDiamond and EBT3 Gafchromic film. Main results . Calculations with Acuros XB dose-to-medium in aluminum differed from the calorimetry data by −2.8% to −3.5%, depending on the beam. Use of dose-to-water would have resulted in about 39% discrepancy. The cross calibration coefficient between water and aluminum yielded values of about 0.87 for the CC13 chamber, 0.91 for the microDiamond, and 0.88 for the film, and independent of the beam within about ±1%. Significance . It was demonstrated the value of the dose-to-medium in aluminum (surrogate of bone) computed with Acuros XB is close to the value of the absolute dose measured with a calorimeter, and there is a significant discrepancy when dose-to-water is used instead. The use of an ionization chamber, a microDiamond and Gafchromic film in aluminum required a considerable correction from calibration in water.
- Open Access
- 24 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics
- Vol. 22 (6) , 50-59
Dosimetry with a clinical linac adapted to FLASH electron beams
Purpose: To assess dosimetric properties and identify required updates to commonly used protocols (including use of film and ionization chamber) pertaining to a clinical linac configured into FLASH (ultra‐high dose rate) electron mode.Methods: An 18MV photon beam of a Varian iX linac was converted to FLASH electron beam by replacing the target and the flattening filter with an electron scattering foil. The dose was prescribed by entering the MUs through the console. Fundamental beam properties, including energy, dose rate, dose reproducibility, field size, and dose rate dependence on the SAD, were examined in preparation for radiobiological experiments. Gafchromic EBT‐XD film was evaluated for usability in measurements at ultra‐high dose rates by comparing the measured dose to the inverse square model. Selected previously reported models of chamber efficiencies were fitted to measurements in a broad range of dose rates.Results: The performance of the modified linac was found adequate for FLASH radiobiological experiments. With exception of the increase in the dose per MU on increase in the repetition rate, all fundamental beam properties proved to be in line with expectations developed with conventional linacs. The field size followed the theorem of similar triangles. The highest average dose rate (2 × 104 Gy/s) was found next to the internal monitor chamber, with the field size of FWHM = 1.5 cm. Independence of the dose readings on the dose rate (up to 2 × 104 Gy/s) was demonstrated for the EBT‐XD film. A model of recombination in an ionization chamber was identified that provided good agreement with the measured chamber efficiencies for the average dose rates up to at least 2 × 103 Gy/s.Conclusion: Dosimetric measurements were performed to characterize a linac converted to FLASH dose rates. Gafchromic EBT‐XD film and dose rate‐corrected cc13 ionization chamber were demonstrated usable at FLASH dose rates.
- 24 May 2021
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics
- Vol. 22 (6) , 50-59
Open AccessDosimetry with a clinical linac adapted to FLASH electron beams
Purpose: To assess dosimetric properties and identify required updates to commonly used protocols (including use of film and ionization chamber) pertaining to a clinical linac configured into FLASH (ultra‐high dose rate) electron mode.Methods: An 18MV photon beam of a Varian iX linac was converted to FLASH electron beam by replacing the target and the flattening filter with an electron scattering foil. The dose was prescribed by entering the MUs through the console. Fundamental beam properties, including energy, dose rate, dose reproducibility, field size, and dose rate dependence on the SAD, were examined in preparation for radiobiological experiments. Gafchromic EBT‐XD film was evaluated for usability in measurements at ultra‐high dose rates by comparing the measured dose to the inverse square model. Selected previously reported models of chamber efficiencies were fitted to measurements in a broad range of dose rates.Results: The performance of the modified linac was found adequate for FLASH radiobiological experiments. With exception of the increase in the dose per MU on increase in the repetition rate, all fundamental beam properties proved to be in line with expectations developed with conventional linacs. The field size followed the theorem of similar triangles. The highest average dose rate (2 × 104 Gy/s) was found next to the internal monitor chamber, with the field size of FWHM = 1.5 cm. Independence of the dose readings on the dose rate (up to 2 × 104 Gy/s) was demonstrated for the EBT‐XD film. A model of recombination in an ionization chamber was identified that provided good agreement with the measured chamber efficiencies for the average dose rates up to at least 2 × 103 Gy/s.Conclusion: Dosimetric measurements were performed to characterize a linac converted to FLASH dose rates. Gafchromic EBT‐XD film and dose rate‐corrected cc13 ionization chamber were demonstrated usable at FLASH dose rates.
- Open Access
- 19 April 2017
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics
- Vol. 18 (3) , 118-129
MLC‐based penumbra softener of EDW borders to reduce junction inhomogeneities
Junctions of fields are known to be susceptible to developing cold or hot spots in the presence of even small geometrical misalignments. Reduction of these dose inhomogeneities can be accomplished through decreasing the dose gradients in the penumbra, but currently it cannot be done for enhanced dynamic wedges (EDW). An MLC‐based penumbra softener was developed in the developer mode of TrueBeam linacs to reduce dose gradients across the side border of EDWs. The movement of each leaf was individually synchronized with the movement of the dynamic Y jaw to soften the penumbra in the same manner along the entire field border, in spite of the presence of the dose gradient of the EDW. Junction homogeneity upon field misalignment for side‐matched EDWs was examined with the MV imager. The fluence inhomogeneities were reduced from about 30% per mm of shift of the field borders for the conventional EDW to about 2% per mm for the softened‐penumbra plan. The junction in a four‐field monoisocentric breast plan delivered to the Rando phantom was assessed with film. The dose inhomogeneities across the junction in the superior‐inferior direction were reduced from about 20% to 25% per mm for the conventional fields to about 5% per mm. The dose near the softened junction of the breast plan with no shifts did not deviate from the conventional plan by more than about 4%. The newly‐developed softened‐penumbra junction of EDW (and/or open) fields was shown to reduce sensitivity to misalignments without increasing complexity of the planning or delivery. This methodology needs to be adopted by the manufacturers for clinical use.
- 19 April 2017
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics
- Vol. 18 (3) , 118-129
Open AccessMLC‐based penumbra softener of EDW borders to reduce junction inhomogeneities
Junctions of fields are known to be susceptible to developing cold or hot spots in the presence of even small geometrical misalignments. Reduction of these dose inhomogeneities can be accomplished through decreasing the dose gradients in the penumbra, but currently it cannot be done for enhanced dynamic wedges (EDW). An MLC‐based penumbra softener was developed in the developer mode of TrueBeam linacs to reduce dose gradients across the side border of EDWs. The movement of each leaf was individually synchronized with the movement of the dynamic Y jaw to soften the penumbra in the same manner along the entire field border, in spite of the presence of the dose gradient of the EDW. Junction homogeneity upon field misalignment for side‐matched EDWs was examined with the MV imager. The fluence inhomogeneities were reduced from about 30% per mm of shift of the field borders for the conventional EDW to about 2% per mm for the softened‐penumbra plan. The junction in a four‐field monoisocentric breast plan delivered to the Rando phantom was assessed with film. The dose inhomogeneities across the junction in the superior‐inferior direction were reduced from about 20% to 25% per mm for the conventional fields to about 5% per mm. The dose near the softened junction of the breast plan with no shifts did not deviate from the conventional plan by more than about 4%. The newly‐developed softened‐penumbra junction of EDW (and/or open) fields was shown to reduce sensitivity to misalignments without increasing complexity of the planning or delivery. This methodology needs to be adopted by the manufacturers for clinical use.
- Open Access
- 6 March 2014
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics
- Vol. 15 (2) , 67-84
On using the dosimetric leaf gap to model the rounded leaf ends in VMAT/RapidArc plans
Partial transmission through rounded leaf ends of Varian multileaf collimators (MLC) is accounted for with a parameter called the dosimetric leaf gap (DLG). Verification of the value of the DLG is needed when the dose delivery is accompanied by gantry rotation in VMAT plans. We compared the doses measured with GAFCHROMIC film and an ionization chamber to treatment planning system (TPS) calculations to identify the optimum values of the DLG in clinical plans of the whole brain with metastases transferred to a phantom. We noticed the absence of a single value of the DLG that properly models all VMAT plans in our cohort (the optimum DLG varied between and ). The former value is considerably different from the optimum DLG in sliding window plans (about 2.0 mm) that approximate IMRT plans. We further found that a single-value DLG model cannot accurately reproduce the measured dose profile even of a uniform static slit at a fixed gantry, which is the simplest MLC-delimited field. The calculation overestimates the measurement in the proximal penumbra, while it underestimates in the distal penumbra. This prompted us to expand the DLG parameter from a plan-specific number to a mathematical concept of the DLG being a function of the distance in the beam's eye view (BEV) between the dose point and the leaf ends. Such function compensates for the difference between the penumbras in a beam delimited with a rounded leaf MLC and delimited with solid jaws. Utilization of this concept allowed us generating a pair of step-and-shoot MLC plans for which we could qualitatively predict the value of the DLG providing best match to ionization chamber measurements. The plan for which the leafs stayed predominantly at positions requiring low values of the DLG (as seen in the profiles of 1D slits) yielded the combined DLG of , while the plan with leafs staying at positions requiring larger values of the DLG yielded the DLG . Considering the DLG to be a function of the distance (in BEV) between the dose point and the leaf ends allowed us to provide an explanation as to why conventional single-number DLG is plan-specific in VMAT plans. PACS numbers: 87.56.jf, 87.56.nk- 6 March 2014
- Published by Wiley in Journal of Applied Clinical Medical Physics
- Vol. 15 (2) , 67-84
Open AccessOn using the dosimetric leaf gap to model the rounded leaf ends in VMAT/RapidArc plans
Partial transmission through rounded leaf ends of Varian multileaf collimators (MLC) is accounted for with a parameter called the dosimetric leaf gap (DLG). Verification of the value of the DLG is needed when the dose delivery is accompanied by gantry rotation in VMAT plans. We compared the doses measured with GAFCHROMIC film and an ionization chamber to treatment planning system (TPS) calculations to identify the optimum values of the DLG in clinical plans of the whole brain with metastases transferred to a phantom. We noticed the absence of a single value of the DLG that properly models all VMAT plans in our cohort (the optimum DLG varied between and ). The former value is considerably different from the optimum DLG in sliding window plans (about 2.0 mm) that approximate IMRT plans. We further found that a single-value DLG model cannot accurately reproduce the measured dose profile even of a uniform static slit at a fixed gantry, which is the simplest MLC-delimited field. The calculation overestimates the measurement in the proximal penumbra, while it underestimates in the distal penumbra. This prompted us to expand the DLG parameter from a plan-specific number to a mathematical concept of the DLG being a function of the distance in the beam's eye view (BEV) between the dose point and the leaf ends. Such function compensates for the difference between the penumbras in a beam delimited with a rounded leaf MLC and delimited with solid jaws. Utilization of this concept allowed us generating a pair of step-and-shoot MLC plans for which we could qualitatively predict the value of the DLG providing best match to ionization chamber measurements. The plan for which the leafs stayed predominantly at positions requiring low values of the DLG (as seen in the profiles of 1D slits) yielded the combined DLG of , while the plan with leafs staying at positions requiring larger values of the DLG yielded the DLG . Considering the DLG to be a function of the distance (in BEV) between the dose point and the leaf ends allowed us to provide an explanation as to why conventional single-number DLG is plan-specific in VMAT plans. PACS numbers: 87.56.jf, 87.56.nk