Comparison of Force Distribution during Laryngoscopy with the C-MAC D-BLADE and Macintosh-Style Blades: A Randomised Controlled Clinical Trial
Open Access
- 29 April 2024
- journal article
- research article
- Published by MDPI AG in Journal of Clinical Medicine
- Vol. 13 (9) , 2623
Abstract
Background: The geometry of a laryngoscope’s blade determines the forces acting on the pharyngeal structures to a relevant degree. Knowledge about the force distribution along the blade may prospectively allow for the development of less traumatic blades. Therefore, we examined the forces along the blades experienced during laryngoscopy with the C-MAC D-BLADE and blades of the Macintosh style. We hypothesised that lower peak forces are applied to the patient’s pharyngeal tissue during videolaryngoscopy with a C-MAC D-BLADE compared to videolaryngoscopy with a C-MAC Macintosh-style blade and direct laryngoscopy with a Macintosh-style blade. Beyond that, we assumed that the distribution of forces along the blade differs depending on the respective blade’s geometry. Methods: After ethical approval, videolaryngoscopy with the D-BLADE or the Macintosh blade, or direct laryngoscopy with the Macintosh blade (all KARL STORZ, Tuttlingen, Germany), was performed on 164 randomly assigned patients. Forces were measured at six positions along each blade and compared with regard to mean force, peak force and spatial distribution. Furthermore, the duration of the laryngoscopy was measured. Results: Mean forces (all p < 0.011) and peak forces at each sensor position (all p < 0.019) were the lowest with the D-BLADE, whereas there were no differences between videolaryngoscopy and direct laryngoscopy with the Macintosh blades (all p > 0.128). With the D-BLADE, the forces were highest at the blade’s tip. In contrast, the forces were more evenly distributed along the Macintosh blades. Videolaryngoscopy took the longest with the D-BLADE (p = 0.007). Conclusions: Laryngoscopy with the D-BLADE resulted in significantly lower forces acting on pharyngeal and laryngeal tissue compared to Macintosh-style blades. Interestingly, with the Macintosh blades, we found no advantage for videolaryngoscopy in terms of force application.Keywords
Funding Information
- the Department of Anaesthesiology and Critical Care, Medical Centre—University of Freiburg
- KARL STORZ SE & Co. KG, Tuttlingen, Germany
- the Open Access Publication Fund of the University of Freiburg
This publication has 25 references indexed in Scilit:
- A comparison of the force applied on oral structures during intubation attempts between the Pentax-AWS airwayscope and the Macintosh laryngoscope: a high-fidelity simulator-based studyBMJ Open, 2014
- Intubation BiomechanicsAnesthesiology, 2014
- Force and pressure distribution using Macintosh and GlideScope laryngoscopes in normal airway: an in vivo study.2013
- Practice Guidelines for Management of the Difficult AirwayAnesthesiology, 2013
- Measurement of forces applied during Macintosh direct laryngoscopy compared with GlideScope ® videolaryngoscopy*Anaesthesia, 2012
- A Comparison of the Forces Applied to a Manikin during Laryngoscopy with the Glidescope ® and Macintosh LaryngoscopesAnaesthesia and Intensive Care, 2011
- Force and pressure distribution using Macintosh and GlideScope laryngoscopes in normal and difficult airways: a manikin studyBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 2011
- CONSORT 2010 Statement: updated guidelines for reporting parallel group randomised trialsBMJ, 2010
- Comparison of two Macintosh laryngoscope blades in 300 patientsBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 2003
- Preoperative assessment for difficult intubation in general and ENT surgery: predictive value of a clinical multivariate risk indexBritish Journal of Anaesthesia, 1998