Is Peer Review Fit for Purpose?
Author:
Open Access
- 1 January 2022
- book chapter
- Published by Springer Nature
- p. 223-241
Abstract
Peer review is endemic to judgement in higher education. It is assumed that when we need to make a judgement on the quality of something—student performance, academic employment, teaching, research and publication—then we may rely on the assessment of peers, whether they be fellow students, lecturers or more senior academics. This chapter will illustrate and challenge this assumption, and assess how ‘fit for purpose’ peer review is in twenty-first century academe. It will focus on different practices of peer review in the contemporary higher education system, it will also question how well they work, how they might be improved and what the alternatives are. The examples to be discussed include refereed journal articles, the assessment of doctoral degrees and the UK Research Excellence Framework (REF).Keywords
This publication has 24 references indexed in Scilit:
- Preparing doctoral candidates for the viva: issues for students and supervisorsJournal of Further and Higher Education, 2012
- Social Policy Excellence – Peer Review or Metrics? Analyzing the 2008 Research Assessment Exercise in Social Work and Social Policy and AdministrationSocial Policy & Administration, 2011
- A Reliability-Generalization Study of Journal Peer Reviews: A Multilevel Meta-Analysis of Inter-Rater Reliability and Its DeterminantsPLOS ONE, 2010
- Negotiation on the assessment of research articles with academic reviewers: application of peer-review approach of teachingHigher Education, 2010
- An ?important contribution? or ?tiresome reading?? A study of evaluation in peer reviews of journal article submissionsJournal of Applied Linguistics, 2004
- The Influence of Peer Review on the Research Assessment ExerciseJournal of Information Science, 2004
- The research assessment exercises 1992–2001: patterns across time and subjectsStudies in Higher Education, 2004
- Reviewing the reviewersQuality in Higher Education, 2003
- Examining the Doctorate: Institutional policy and the PhD examination process in BritainStudies in Higher Education, 2000
- Peer-review practices of psychological journals: The fate of published articles, submitted againBehavioral and Brain Sciences, 1982