We need to talk about values: a proposed framework for the articulation of normative reasoning in health technology assessment
Authors:
- Victoria CharltonVCVictoria Charlton
- Michael DiStefanoMDMichael DiStefano
- Polly MitchellPMPolly Mitchell
- Liz MorrellLMLiz Morrell
- Leah RandLRLeah Rand
- Gabriele BadanoGBGabriele Badano
- Rachel BakerRBRachel Baker
- Michael CalnanMCMichael Calnan
- Kalipso ChalkidouKCKalipso Chalkidou
- Anthony CulyerACAnthony Culyer
- Daniel HowdonDHDaniel Howdon
- Dyfrig HughesDHDyfrig Hughes
Open Access
- 27 September 2023
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in Health Economics, Policy and Law
- Vol. 19 (2) , 153-173
Abstract
It is acknowledged that health technology assessment (HTA) is an inherently value-based activity that makes use of normative reasoning alongside empirical evidence. But the language used to conceptualise and articulate HTA's normative aspects is demonstrably unnuanced, imprecise, and inconsistently employed, undermining transparency and preventing proper scrutiny of the rationales on which decisions are based. This paper – developed through a cross-disciplinary collaboration of 24 researchers with expertise in healthcare priority-setting – seeks to address this problem by offering a clear definition of key terms and distinguishing between the types of normative commitment invoked during HTA, thus providing a novel conceptual framework for the articulation of reasoning. Through application to a hypothetical case, it is illustrated how this framework can operate as a practical tool through which HTA practitioners and policymakers can enhance the transparency and coherence of their decision-making, while enabling others to hold them more easily to account. The framework is offered as a starting point for further discussion amongst those with a desire to enhance the legitimacy and fairness of HTA by facilitating practical public reasoning, in which decisions are made on behalf of the public, in public view, through a chain of reasoning that withstands ethical scrutiny.Keywords
Funding Information
- Wellcome Trust (203351/Z/16/Z)
This publication has 53 references indexed in Scilit:
- Societal Values in the Allocation of Healthcare ResourcesThe Patient - Patient-Centered Outcomes Research, 2011
- Health technology prioritization: Which criteria for prioritizing new technologies and what are their relative weights?Health Policy, 2011
- Pharmacoeconomics: NICE's approach to decision‐makingBritish Journal of Clinical Pharmacology, 2010
- Political Theory and Practical Public ReasoningPolitical Studies, 2010
- Why ethics should be part of health technology assessmentInternational Journal of Technology Assessment in Health Care, 2008
- Ethical analysis to improve decision-making on health technologiesBulletin of the World Health Organization, 2008
- The NICE Cost-Effectiveness ThresholdPharmacoEconomics, 2008
- Deliberative processes and evidence-informed decision making in healthcare: do they work and how might we know?Evidence & Policy, 2006
- National Institute for Clinical Excellence and its value judgmentsBMJ, 2004
- Political Legitimacy and DemocracyEthics, 2002