CT image quality evaluation in the age of deep learning: trade-off between functionality and fidelity
- 9 November 2022
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Springer Nature in European Radiology
- Vol. 33 (4) , 2439-2449
Abstract
Objective To quantitatively compare DLIR and ASiR-V with realistic anatomical images. Methods CT scans of an anthropomorphic phantom were acquired using three routine protocols (brain, chest, and abdomen) at four dose levels, with images reconstructed at five levels of ASiR-V and three levels of DLIR. Noise power spectrum (NPS) was estimated using a difference image by subtracting two matching images from repeated scans. Using the max-dose FBP reconstruction as the ground truth, the structure similarity index (SSIM) and gradient magnitude (GM) of difference images were evaluated. Image noise magnitude (σ), frequency location of the NPS peak (fpeak), mean SSIM (MSSIM), and mean GM (MGM) were used as quantitative metrics to compare image quality, for each anatomical region, protocol, algorithm, dose level, and slice thickness. Results Image noise had a strong (R2 > 0.99) power law relationship with dose for all algorithms. For the abdomen and chest, fpeak shifted from 0.3 (FBP) down to 0.15 mm-1 (ASiR-V 100%) with increasing ASiR-V strength but remained 0.3 mm-1 for all DLIR levels. fpeak shifted down for the brain protocol with increasing DLIR levels. Three levels of DLIR produced similar image noise levels as ASiR-V 40%, 80%, and 100%, respectively. DLIR had lower MSSIM but higher MGM than ASiR-V while matching imaging noise. Conclusion Compared to ASiR-V, DLIR presents trade-offs between functionality and fidelity: it has a noise texture closer to FBP and more edge enhancement, but reduced structure similarity. These trade-offs and unique protocol-dependent behaviors of DLIR should be considered during clinical implementation and deployment. Key Points • DLIR reconstructed images demonstrate closer noise texture and lower structure similarity to FBP while producing equivalent noise levels comparable to ASiR-V. • DLIR has additional edge enhancement as compared to ASiR-V. • DLIR has unique protocol-dependent behaviors that should be considered for clinical implementation.Keywords
This publication has 22 references indexed in Scilit:
- Improving Image Quality and Reducing Radiation Dose for Pediatric CT by Using Deep Learning ReconstructionRadiology, 2021
- CT iterative vs deep learning reconstruction: comparison of noise and sharpnessEuropean Radiology, 2020
- Validation of deep-learning image reconstruction for coronary computed tomography angiography: Impact on noise, image quality and diagnostic accuracyJournal of Cardiovascular Computed Tomography, 2020
- Image Quality Assessment of Abdominal CT by Use of New Deep Learning Image Reconstruction: Initial ExperienceAmerican Journal of Roentgenology, 2020
- Noise and spatial resolution properties of a commercially available deep learning‐based CT reconstruction algorithmMedical Physics, 2020
- Image Quality and Lesion Detection on Deep Learning Reconstruction and Iterative Reconstruction of Submillisievert Chest and Abdominal CTAmerican Journal of Roentgenology, 2020
- Image quality and dose reduction opportunity of deep learning image reconstruction algorithm for CT: a phantom studyEuropean Radiology, 2020
- Deep Learning–based CT Image Reconstruction: Initial Evaluation Targeting Hypovascular Hepatic MetastasesRadiology: Artificial Intelligence, 2019
- Statistical model based iterative reconstruction (MBIR) in clinical CT systems: Experimental assessment of noise performanceMedical Physics, 2014
- Image quality assessment: from error visibility to structural similarityIEEE Transactions on Image Processing, 2004