Experimental study on the stability of osteosynthesis for a fracture of the suprahumeral process and the scapular spine with a bone tissue defect using bone plates
Open Access
- 24 April 2026
- journal article
- Published by Publishing House Zaslavsky in TRAUMA
- Vol. 27 (2) , 90-99
Abstract
Background. The frequency of scapular fractures in military personnel who were in the combat zone is approximately 20 times higher than among the civilian population. The probable cause of fixation failures is insufficient stability of the structure, especially in cases of bone tissue defect. One of the possible ways to increase the strength of osteosynthesis is the use of two plates located in an orthogonal plane. The purpose was to study in an experiment the stabilizing properties of different variants of osteosynthesis for fragments of a fracture of the suprahumeral process and the scapular spine with a bone tissue defect using bone plates. Materials and methods. The study was performed on anatomical models of the scapula made of high-density polyurethane. To reproduce the fracture, a simulated defect of the suprahumeral process and the scapular spine with a length of 20 mm was created. Two variants of osteosynthesis were studied — with one and two plates (5 samples each). The amount of movement of the scapular fragments under the influence of loading in two planes, vertical and horizontal, was determined. The loading was increased from 0 to 50 N in increments of 10 N. Results. Osteosynthesis of the suprahumeral process of the scapula with one plate provides stable fixation of the fragments only in the vertical plane, when the loading acts perpendicular to the plane of the bone plate. In this case, the displacement of the process is possible only if the metal plate is deformed. Under the influence of the load in the horizontal plane, the largest displacements are noted, since the force acts parallel to the plane of the plate, and the resistance to it is provided exclusively by the fixing screws. Thus, the disadvantage of osteosynthesis with one plate is its effectiveness only in counteracting loads in the vertical plane. The imposition of two plates on the upper and front surfaces of the humeral process ensures stability of the structure both under vertical and horizontal loads. The small difference in the displacement values between these options is due to the geometric features of the plates: the lateral plate had a smaller thickness compared to the upper one, which reduced its resistance to horizontal loads. Conclusions. The stability of the model of fixation for a fracture of the humeral process and the spine of the scapula with a bone tissue defect significantly depends on the configuration of osteosynthesis and the direction of the applied load. Fixation with one plate on the upper surface of the clavicle provides relatively effective resistance to vertical loads, however, with horizontal loading, a significant increase in the movement of fragments is observed, which indicates insufficient rigidity of the structure in this plane. In contrast, fixation with two plates provides significantly smaller movements of the suprahumeral process under loads in both planes, which indicates increased rigidity and stability of the structure.Keywords
This publication has 11 references indexed in Scilit:
- Experimental study of the stability of osteosynthesis of the clavicle with bone plates in case of a fracture of its suprahumeral end with a bone tissue defectTRAUMA, 2025
- Posterior Approach for Open Reduction and Internal Fixation for Scapular FracturesJBJS Essential Surgical Techniques, 2023
- Nonunion of the so-called acromion: a systematic review with consideration of the terminologyArchives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery, 2023
- Single or Double Plating for Acromial Type III Fractures: Biomechanical Comparison of Load to Failure and Fragment MotionJournal of Clinical Medicine, 2022
- Treatment strategies for scapular spine fractures: a scoping reviewEFORT Open Reviews, 2021
- Surgical treatment of scapular fractures: Results and complicationsInjury, 2021
- Scapula fractures: a reviewEFORT Open Reviews, 2021
- Double plating is associated with higher fixation strength than single plating in osteoporotic fractures of the scapular spine: a biomechanical studyArchives of orthopaedic and trauma surgery, 2021
- Outcomes following extra-articular fractures of the scapula: A systematic reviewInjury, 2020
- A review of 10 years of scapula injuries sustained by UK military personnel on operationsJournal of the Royal Army Medical Corps, 2017