Logic in the 1930s: Type Theory and Model Theory
- 5 September 2013
- journal article
- research article
- Published by Cambridge University Press (CUP) in The Bulletin of Symbolic Logic
- Vol. 19 (4) , 433-472
Abstract
In historical discussions of twentieth-century logic, it is typically assumed that model theory emerged within the tradition that adopted first-order logic as the standard framework. Work within the type-theoretic tradition, in the style ofPrincipia Mathematica, tends to be downplayed or ignored in this connection. Indeed, the shift from type theory to first-order logic is sometimes seen as involving a radical break that first made possible the rise of modern model theory. While comparing several early attempts to develop the semantics of axiomatic theories in the 1930s, by two proponents of the type-theoretic tradition (Carnap and Tarski) and two proponents of the first-order tradition (Gödel and Hilbert), we argue that, instead, the move from type theory to first-order logic is better understood as a gradual transformation, and further, that the contributions to semantics made in the type-theoretic tradition should be seen as central to the evolution of model theory.Keywords
This publication has 39 references indexed in Scilit:
- CARNAP ON EXTREMAL AXIOMS, “COMPLETENESS OF THE MODELS,” AND CATEGORICITYThe Review of Symbolic Logic, 2012
- Fixed‐ versus Variable‐domain Interpretations of Tarski’s Account of Logical ConsequencePhilosophy Compass, 2010
- REREADING TARSKI ON LOGICAL CONSEQUENCEThe Review of Symbolic Logic, 2009
- The indefinability of truth in the “Wahrheitsbegriff”Annals of Pure and Applied Logic, 2004
- On tarski on modelsThe Journal of Symbolic Logic, 2001
- Tarski on Logical ConsequenceNotre Dame Journal of Formal Logic, 1996
- Frege, hilbert, and the conceptual structure of model theoryHistory and Philosophy of Logic, 1994
- Logic in the twenties: the nature of the quantifierThe Journal of Symbolic Logic, 1979
- Comparison of Russell's resolution of the semantical antinomies with that of TarskiThe Journal of Symbolic Logic, 1976
- Ein Gültigkeitskriterium für die Sätze der klassischen MathematikMonatshefte für Mathematik, 1935